The Great Famine-Genocide in Soviet Ukraine (Holodomor)

  back    
MR. SULZBERGER: "TEAR DOWN THIS WALL!"
  

Letter to Arthur Sulzberger, Jr., Publisher, NY Times
By Volodymyr Kurylo, President,
United Ukrainian American Organizations of Greater New York
New York, NY, Thursday, October 23, 2003

 

Dear Mr. Sulzberger:

On November 15, 2003, thousands of Ukrainians and friends of Ukraine and her people will participate in a "March of Remembrance" from St. George Ukrainian Church on 7th Street - to St. Patrick's Cathedral. At 11:45AM, they will begin to solemnly walk to honor the victims of the Ukrainian Famine Genocide of 1932-1933.

 

November 15th and the "March of Remembrance" will soon be upon us. In the days and weeks before the March, Ukrainians, friends of Ukraine and her people, people who respect and expect truth in the media, "at a time of their choosing", will assemble in front of & near your building to bring attention to the seventy year old Duranty scandal and the NYT reluctance to appropriately expose Soviet-era crimes and criminals.

 

Almost seventy years ago, the New York Times reported about a similar march. Reading the reports about the "parade" of 1933, one gets a sense of the battle waged between ideologies in the streets of New York while most Americans "slept". Seventy years later, has much changed? Seventy years later, will the New York Times dare to cover the "March of Remembrance"?

 

MR. SULZBERGER: "TEAR DOWN THIS WALL!"

 

On November 18, 1933, when 6000 Ukrainians gathered in Washington Square in New York City, they knew something about evil. It took fifty years and President Ronald Reagan to call the Soviet Union what it really was. On March 8, 1983, in his address to the National Association of Evangelicals he stated that the United States was at war with an "evil empire".

 

Soon after they declared their independence on January 22, 1918, Ukrainians realized that their days of freedom were numbered. The banner of Russian chauvinism, imperialism and oppression was now in the hands of hammer & sickle wielding atheists. On November 19, 1933, the New York Times reported that "Three hundred policemen, including a score of mounted men, were called out to enable the marchers to reach the opera house and to conduct a meeting there in peace". Why were three hundred policemen needed?

 

The Ukrainians were merely holding a "parade" from Washington Square to the Central Opera House at Sixty-seventh Street and Third Avenue. On November 16, President Roosevelt embraced "Uncle Joe" Stalin by recognizing the USSR. Ukrainians were merely "asking President Roosevelt to demand that the famine in the Ukraine would be alleviated. The resolutions charged that the food shortage was a result of a deliberate plot by the Moscow government to starve the Ukrainian peasants into submission". Who could possibly object to this urgent and merciful mission.

 

While Stalin's genocidal famine was starving millions, communists, disciples of bolshevism were waging a battle for America's soul. On the morning of November 18, 1933, they mustered 500 followers. "The first clash occurred at the southern end of the square. There was a free-for-all fight, during which Patrolman Edgar Denham.said he was beaten and kicked by Communists. Patrolman Denham arrested a man who identified himself as Dolia Mishna".

 

"When the Ukrainian parade reached University Place and Ninth Street, according to the police, a group of Communists attacked the marchers.The police drove off the attackers and chased them through side streets. After a melee five men were arrested. These prisoners identified themselves as Philip Kaplan, a relief worker for the city.George Mitchell.Wayne Herman Helm. Leon Zartarin.and John Henchiuk. Kaplan was charged with striking Detective Thomas Jenkins of the alien squad, who was badly beaten and had cuts over his eyes."

 

This was a relentless and devoted band of Bolshevik disciples who was punishing Ukrainians for exposing the truth & trying to save their mothers, fathers, brothers and sisters from intentional starvation, execution and exile to Siberia. The New York Times continued its "blow by blow" description: "At Twenty-eighth Street and Lexington Avenue the police again dispersed a crowd of Communists who lined both sidewalks, jeering and throwing bottles, sticks and brickbats at the marchers. Similar incidents occurred at Thirty-fifth Street, at Fiftieth Street and at Sixty-sixth Street.

 

At Sixty-sixth Street and Lexington Avenue Patrolman Frank J. Smith arrested a man who said he was David Crotto.The policeman was badly beaten, knocked down and kicked in the back by several men who tried to get his prisoner away from him but he held on until another policemen rescued him.

 

Two others were arrested near the opera house on disorderly conduct charges. They said they were Manuel Rivera and Edith Rubin. The complainant against these two was Paul Papura who said he had been beaten."

 

"The police established lines all around the opera house, keeping a crowd of yelling Communists at safe distance while the Ukrainians entered.When the meeting was over, the Ukrainians left the opera house without being molested". The Times described the arsenal of weapons American Communists utilized in their fight against truth, against free speech and against the right of peaceful assembly: "A large collection of iron pipes, chair rungs, milk bottles, pop bottles and glass jars, some filled with liquids and grease was taken from prisoners and found in the streets after the rioting".

 

In what appears to be a harbinger of some of today's "liberal" justice, we learn that: "Arraigned in Night Court before Magistrate Goldstein, Rivera was found guilty, but sentence was suspended. The complaints against Crotto and Miss Rubin were dismissed".

 

Seventy years later, the New York Times still clings to Walter Duranty's ill-gotten Pulitzer. Sig Gissler, administrator of The Pulitzer Prizes, clings to the technicality that "As a matter of clarity, it is worth noting that the 1932 award was for an explicit set of stories in 1931, which is before the famine of 1932-1933 hit with full force".

 

Fortunately, Leonard Leshuk, author of "US Intelligence Perceptions of Soviet Power 1921-1946" (Frank Cass Publishers, London, 2003) offers, as a matter of clarity, a document worth noting: Gordon Dispatch, 5 June 931, NARG 59 861.5017 LC/268. On page 76 of Mr. Leshuk's book, we find:

The US news media had a great influence on how those in the intelligence agencies, and the policy makers, as well as the general public, viewed the USSR. The reliability and objectivity of US newspapers concerning the Soviets, as well as their ethics and those of their reporters, can be judged from the statement of Walter Duranty of the New York Times who admitted to A.W. Klieforth of the US Embassy in Berlin in June of 1931 that, '"in agreement with The New York Times and the Soviet authorities," his official dispatches always reflect the official opinion of the Soviet regime and not his own'.

 

So, as a matter of clarity, can we state that Walter Duranty was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for reflecting, in the year for which he won his prize, "the official opinion of the Soviet regime and not his own"? As a matter of clarity, it is worth noting that during the seventy years that have passed, the New York Times has not summoned enough courage, commandeered enough ethics nor evolved into sufficient morality to admit that it collaborated in trafficking in the falsifications and denials of the most lied about and concealed genocide in the history of man's inhumanity to man - the Ukrainian Famine Genocide of 1932-1933 - the "Holodomor" - the "Hidden Holocaust".

 

Both the New York Times and Walter Duranty were probably relieved when Soviet Foreign Commissar, Maxim Litvinov, in his January 3, 1934, response to the attention drawn to the famine by Congressman Herman Kopelman of Connecticut, for the sake of clarity wrote: "I am in receipt of your letter of the 14th instant and thank you for drawing my attention to the Ukrainian pamphlet.

 

There is any amount of such pamphlets full of lies circulated by the counter-revolutionary organizations abroad who specialize in work of this kind. There is nothing left for them to do but spread false information and forge documents" and of course, defend themselves against pipe-wielding American devotees of Bolshevism. Thank God that Mr. Litvinov put all those nasty rumors to rest.

 

Mr. Sulzberger, the time has come to "tear down this wall", the wall that has concealed a seventy year old scandal, the wall that has obscured the crimes of Stalin and his henchmen, Lazar Kaganovych, Vyacheslav Molotov and a legion of others. Americans must not be kept ignorant about the millions of victims and the criminals who were responsible for crimes against humanity.

 

During the height of the Ukrainian Famine/Genocide, Molotov and Kaganovych created a draconian law to shoot starving peasants who stole even husks of grain. In his 1998, article "Remembering Ukraine's Unknown Holocaust", Eric Margolis wrote: "When OGPU failed to meet weekly execution quotas, Stalin sent henchman Lazar Kaganovitch to destroy Ukrainian resistance. Kaganovitch, the Soviet Eichmann, made quota, shooting 10,000 Ukrainians weekly".

 

Mr. Sulzberger, the New York Times has been "comforting" and concealing Soviet-era criminals for seventy years. Lazar Kaganovitch died in Moscow of natural causes in 1991, at the age of 98. How could a man with so much blood on his hands have eluded the appropriate, the moral, the just condemnation of at least one of your prize winning journalists? Mr. Sulzberger, the time has come to "tear down this wall" of deceit and to issue an appropriate mea culpa.

 

The Jayson Blair scandal resulted in four full pages of atonement. How many pages are the lives of over seven million innocent Ukrainians worth. How many pages are seventy years of denials, falsifications and concealment worth. It is not enough to quietly give back a Pulitzer accepted while standing on the corpses of millions of innocent victims. Do the right thing!


Letter Written By Volodymyr Kurylo, President,
United Ukrainian American Organizations of Greater New York
New York, NY, October 23, 2003
(917) 861-1574,  vkurylo@aol.com
 
 

  back