|
|
"Historical tragedies never disappear and are never forgotten. The terrible
interethnic conflict between Ukrainians and Poles in Volyn, which claimed
tens of thousands of human lives in 1943-1944 on two warring sides, was
hushed up in this country for decades: even in the already independent
1990s, this subject seemed to be taboo." [article number five]
"Ukraine Report 2003," Number 51 Ukraine Market Reform Group (UMRG) ArtUkraine Information Service (ARTUIS) Kyiv, Ukraine and Washington, D.C.
WEEKEND EDITION, May 31-June 1, 2003
INDEX OF ARTICLES:
1. UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT BOASTS ECONOMIC GROWTH
DWELLS ON POLITICS
Kuchma says Viktor Yushchenko Made the Wrong Decision
Ukrainian Television first programme, Kiev, in Ukrainian, 28 May 03
BBC Monitoring Service, UK, in English, May 28, 2003
2. ENERGY AND UKRAINE'S EURO-ATLANTIC FUTURE
U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine Carlos Pascual, Sixth International
Conference, "Energy Security of Europe in the XXI Century"
Energy Security Forum, Kyiv, Ukraine, May 28, 2003
3. SHEVCHENKO AWARDED UKRAINE'S TOP SPORTS HONOR
AC Milan Soccer Striker Andriy Shevchenko
Reuters News Service, Kyiv, Ukraine, May 30, 2003
4. U.S. LAWMAKERS PLEAD CASE OF JAILED FORMER
AGRICULTURE OFFICIAL IN UKRAINE
By Tim Vickery, Associated Press Writer
The Associated Press, Kyiv, Ukraine, Friday, May 30, 2003
5-A. VOLYN 1943-1944, AN UNKNOWN TRAGEDY
The Terrible Interethnic Conflict Between Ukrainians and Poles in Volyn
National dignity means truth for ourselves and our descendants.
Prepared by Serhiy Makhun, Ihor Siundiukov, Vyacheslav Darpinyants,
and Mykhailo Mazurin, THE DAY Weekly Digest in Two Parts
Part I, May 13, 2003; Part II, May 27, 2003, Kyiv, Ukraine
5-B. UKRAINIAN LAWMAKERS DIVIDED OVER ASSESSMENT
OF VOLYN MASSACRE IN 1943
RFE/RL NEWSLINE, Prague, Czech Republic, May 30, 2003
6. RUSSIA'S LARGEST BREWER BALTIKA BREWERY OPENS ITS
FIRST OFFICE IN UKRAINE TO EXPAND SALES
Just-Drinks.com Editorial Team, Bromsgrove, Worcs, UK, May 30, 2003
7. RECONSTRUCTION OF ANCIENT CHURCH BEGINS IN KYIV
Original Church was Destroyed in 1970 During Soviet Times
R.I.S.U., Lviv, Ukraine, May 24, 2003
8. POLISH PAINT PRODUCER HAS GOOD RESULTS
Polifarb built a production plant in Ukraine
Polish News Bulletin, Warsaw, Poland, May 29, 2003
9. UKRAINIAN NEWSPAPER SAYS BRITAIN IS ON "FREE SPEECH"
BANDWAGON AGAINST UKRAINE
Ukrainian Weekly Newspaper 2000 in Russian, May 30, 2003
BBC Monitoring Service, UK, in English, May 30, 2003
10. STUDENTS COME TO MASSACHUSETTS FROM UKRAINE
Four Ukrainian Teenagers from Butch, a town of 14,000 in western Ukraine
Lisa Press, Hamilton Wenham Chronicle, Town.com
Hamilton, Massachusetts, May 28, 2003
11. UKRAINIAN GREEK CATHOLIC RELIGIOUS LEADER CARDINAL
LUBOMYR HUSSAR IN CHICAGO TO INSTALL NEW BISHOP
Ukrainian Greek Catholics in the USA greet the religious leader
By Ron Grossman, Tribune staff reporter
Chicago Tribune Online, Chicago, Illinois, May 29, 2003
12.MOSCOW EXHIBIT CELEBRATES A SOVIET-ERA INTELLIGENCE
AGENCY SMERSH, "DEATH TO SPIES," RUTHLESS IN UKRAINE
SMERSH fought the Ukrainian Nationalist Movement
SMERSH "acted very ruthlessly" in Ukraine, sometimes destroying villages
that had helped the nationalists and sending the entire surviving
populations to Siberia. David Holley, Staff Writer for the Los Angeles Times
Los Angeles Times, Los Angeles, California, May 25, 2003
13. UK CHARTER FIRM IN AIR CRASH ROW
Firm Brokered Hiring of Aircraft Belonging to Ukrainian Mediterranean
Airlines. V. Gorbanovskyi, deputy director of UM Air, defends airplane.
Passenger called home and said, "Pray for me, this airplane is shit."
Giles Tremlett in Madrid, David Pallister in London
The Guardian Newspaper Online, UK, Friday, May 30, 2003
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER ONE
1. UKRAINIAN PRESIDENT BOASTS ECONOMIC GROWTH
DWELLS ON POLITICS
Kuchma says Viktor Yushchenko Made the Wrong Decision
Ukrainian Television first programme, Kiev, in Ukrainian, 28 May 03
BBC Monitoring Service, UK, in English, May 28, 2003
This has been the best year since 1999 in terms of economic performance
despite serious problems in the energy sector, Ukrainian President Leonid
Kuchma has told a news conference. Speaking about a political reform
initiative he put forward, Kuchma said no constitutional changes will be
made in violation of Ukrainian laws.
He also regretted that popular reformist Viktor Yushchenko had joined the
opposition, adding that the opposition had the right to stage protests.
Ukraine's developing economic cooperation with the CIS does not hinder
Kiev's European integration, Kuchma said. He also indicated that Ukrainian
Foreign Minister Anatoliy Zlenko may retire because of old age and said he
was worried by regional differences in Ukraine.
-
TO READ THE ENTIRE TEXT OF THE INTERVIEW WITH THE
PRESIDENT KUCHMA ON UKRAINIAN TV CLICK ON:
-
http://www.artukraine.com/buildukraine/kuchma_boasts.htm
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER TWO
2. ENERGY AND UKRAINE'S EURO-ATLANTIC FUTURE
U.S. Ambassador to Ukraine Carlos Pascual
Sixth International Conference, "Energy Security of Europe in the
XXI Century," Energy Security Forum, Kyiv, Ukraine, May 28, 2003
Energy markets are global. Supplies of oil and gas come from every corner
of the globe - the Caspian, Russia, Middle East, Africa, South America and
North America. Importers determine their energy sources by the price and
quality offered, seeking the most competitive source for their needs.
Increasingly the quality of fuel and high environmental standards affect
supply choices. To succeed in this international market, countries must be
able to compete as suppliers and transporters and as efficient users of the
energy they consume.
Ukraine is a player in this global market. The actions Ukraine takes in the
coming years will fundamentally determine whether it plays this market to
its advantage and secures a place as a European transit hub. There is much
to build on. Ukraine is blessed with a wealth of natural resources,
substantial domestic production potential and one of the largest oil and gas
pipeline infrastructures in the world.
Due to its strategic location between oil and gas suppliers in Russia,
Central Asia and the Caspian Basin and consumers in Europe, Ukraine is also
a key transport country. Clearly. Ukraine has the foundation to ensure its
own energy security and integrate politically and economically with Europe.
With the right policy choices and a long-term energy Strategy. Ukraine has
all the resources at hand for success.
-
TO READ THE ENTIRE IMPORTANT ENERGY PRESENTATION
BY AMBASSADOR PASCUAL CLICK ON THE FOLLOWING LINK:
-
http://www.artukraine.com/buildukraine/pascualsp5.htm
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER THREE
3. SHEVCHENKO AWARDED UKRAINE'S TOP SPORTS HONOR
AC Milan Soccer Striker Andriy Shevchenko
Reuters News Service, Kyiv, Ukraine, May 30, 2003
KYIV, Ukraine..May 30...AC Milan striker Andriy Shevchenko has been
awarded Ukraine's "Merited Master of Sports" honor by the country's State
Sports Committee, it was announced on Friday.
Shevchenko scored the decisive penalty in a shootout to give Milan a 3-2
victory over rival Italians Juventus in Wednesday's Champions League final.
"The Merited Master of Sports" is Ukraine's highest sports honor, a legacy
from the Soviet era usually presented to Olympic or world champions.
The Dynamo Kiev teams which won the European Cup Winners' Cup in
1975 and 1986 were the last Ukrainian footballers to receive this honor.
SHEVCHENKO HEADS UKRAINE SQUAD FOR EURO 2004
KIEV, May 31 (Reuters) - AC Milan striker Andriy Shevchenko heads a 27-man
strong Ukraine squad named on Saturday for next month's Euro 2004 Group Six
qualifiers against Armenia and Greece.
Ukraine coach Leonid Buryak also called up one newcomer, Shakhtar Donetsk
midfielder Adrian Pukanych, for the games at home against Armenia on June 7
and away to Greece four days later.
Club Bruges midfielder Serhiy Serebrennikov will miss both games with a knee
injury, while Shakhtar's Anatoly Tymoshchyuk is suspended for the Armenia
match. Buryak has singled out the game in Athens as the most important.
"It will be crucial for us to do well there because that match will probably
decide second place in our group," he said. "Anyway, I expect at least four
points from these two games."
Ukraine and Greece have six points each from four matches, while the
Armenians have four points. Spain lead the group on 10 points. Squad:
Goalkeepers: Olexander Shovkovsky, Vitaly Reva (both Dynamo Kiev), Dmytro
Shutkov (Shakhtar Donetsk)
Defenders: Oleh Luzhny (Arsenal), Olexander Holovko, Andriy Nesmachny, Yuri
Dmitrulin, Serhiy Fyodorov (all Dynamo Kiev), Olexander Radchenko, Volodymyr
Yezersky (both Dnipro Dnipropetrovsk), Serhiy Popov (Shakhtar Donetsk),
Vyacheslav Shevchyuk (Shinnik Yaroslavl)
Midfielders: Adrian Pukanych, Anatoly Tymoshchyuk (both Shakhtar Donetsk),
Andriy Husin (Dynamo Kiev), Serhiy Zakarlyuka (Metalurg Donetsk), Serhiy
Kormiltsev (Torpedo Moscow), Maxim Kalinichenko (Spartak Moscow), Olexander
Gorshkov (Saturn Ramenskoye), Olexander Prizetko, Serhiy Snytko (both
Chernomorets Novorossiisk), Denis Onishchenko (Hapoel Tel Aviv)
Forwards: Andriy Shevchenko (AC Milan), Serhiy Rebrov (Fenerbahce), Andriy
Vorobei (Shakhtar Donetsk), Oleh Venglinsky (Dnipro Dnipropetrovsk), Andriy
Voronin (FSV Mainz, Germany) (UMRG-ARTUIS)
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER FOUR
4. U.S. LAWMAKERS PLEAD CASE OF JAILED FORMER
AGRICULTURE OFFICIAL IN UKRAINE
By Tim Vickery, Associated Press Writer
The Associated Press, Kyiv, Ukraine, Friday, May 30, 2003
KIEV, Ukraine (AP) - Leading Ukraine backers in the U.S. Congress
have sent a letter to President Leonid Kuchma complaining that the
arrest of a former high-profile agriculture official and steps to reimpose
state control over the grain market threaten to derail key reforms and
drive out international investors.
The letter signed by U.S. Reps. Marcy Kaptur and Curt Weldon,
co-chairs of the Congressional Ukrainian Caucus, hailed the former
Soviet republic's "major accomplishments" in privatizing much of the
agricultural sector. But in the letter dated Thursday they also expressed
"growing concern" that the "continued detention of a leading advocate
of reform has had a chilling impact on market sentiment" among domestic
and foreign business leaders.
The lawmakers also urged Kuchma to "take whatever steps necessary"
to ensure an open, transparent agricultural market. They claim that some
Ukrainian officials have begun lobbying for greater government intervention
in grain markets to control prices after harsh weather wiped out the bulk
of Ukraine's winter crop in some regions.
This month, prosecutors opened a criminal case against Leonid
Kozachenko, who won the praise of business and Western governments
for advocating market-based reforms as head of Ukraine's agriculture
policy before being ousted in a Cabinet reshuffle in November. Prosecutors
accuse him of abusing his office by allowing underpriced grain exports
that cost the government US$283 million.
Prosecutors also claim Kozachenko received some US$282,000
in bribes from two prominent European companies while director of the
Ukrahrobiznes concern prior to joining the government.
Kozachenko, who now heads a confederation of agribusiness
organizations, has denied the charges. He has been in pretrial detention
since March.
The case against him was among dozens opened after Kuchma
ordered prosecutors to investigate corruption in the grain market that it
claims caused a critical shortage of grain in Ukraine, once the Soviet
Union's breadbasket.
Kaptur and Weldon pressed Kuchma to ensure that Kozachenko
is "treated fairly and afforded his freedom if no evidence exists of
wrongdoing."
Agriculture business leaders, reformist lawmakers and former Prime
Minister Anatoliy Kinakh have claimed the charges against Kozachenko
were trumped up to disguise the government's failure to implement
key reforms or allow shady deals to go forward.
One of the world's largest grain exporters, Ukraine plans to import
grain this year after severe weather destroyed up to 90 percent of the
winter crop in some regions. (tv/bh)
ENTIRE TEXT OF THE LETTER TO PRESIDENT KUCHMA
FROM UKRAINIAN CONGRESSIONAL CAUCUS LEADERS
MARCY KAPTUR AND KURT WELDON
CONGRESS OF THE UNITED STATES
Washington, D.C. 20515
May 29, 2003
President Leonid Kuchma
Kyiv, Ukraine
Dear President Kuchma:
We are writing to express our growing concern that our joint efforts to
encourage agricultural transformation and reform may be facing new
challenges that threaten progress made over the past decade. As you once
stated during a visit to our Capitol, to achieve agricultural reform in
Ukraine is an enormous undertaking, one that "we much begin and then
finish." We appreciate your leadership in this regard.
Without question, in the past few years Ukraine has made considerable
progress in privatizing and restructuring its agricultural sector as a
necessary step in NATO accession and WTO inclusion. We applaud
the Rada's passage of important legislation to created private land
ownership. Open markets are beginning to take root. Nevertheless, in
the wake of higher grain prices following a harsh winter and a difficult
spring, we have seen some in Ukraine question the benefit of an open
agricultural market governed by a transparent legal system, and we hear
some calls for greater government intervention in grain markets. We
very much would like to continue working with you to stay the course
in the development of a market-oriented agricultural sector and to assist
you in dealing with the voices of doubt. We applaud the Cabinet of
Ministers in its voiced commitment to free markets with the agricultural
sector.
Perhaps the greatest progress in the past few years have been the
privatization of State controlled elevators, accompanied by an expanding
base of domestic and international private grain traders, as well as,
the privatization of agriculture land. These reforms are substantial
steps forward. You and your government are to be congratulated for
these major accomplishments.
Recent events, such as the detention of Mr. Leonid Kozachenko,
have caused us to become concerned that these achievements, as well
as future progress in agricultural reform may be endangered. The
Government of Ukraine obviously must uphold and prosecute the law,
but the continued detention of a leading advocate of reform has had
a chilling impact on market sentiment. As well as, raise concerns about
continued discussion among some government officials regarding the
need to re-establish regional grain reserves and about the recent
appointment of Khlib Ukrainiy as the State Agent for intervention
grain purchases.
These actions have created considerable doubt and uncertainly
among private Ukrainian and international investors and business
leaders.
We are confident that the efficient functioning of Ukraine's grain market
will continue to develop and should ensure the availability of sufficient,
high-quality grain at reasonable prices even in the face of low domestic
production. In that light, we urge you to take whatever steps are
necessary to put an end to the uncertainly that these actions have caused.
We also respectfully request that your government ensure that Mr.
Kozachenko , who is widely respected in Ukraine, the United States
and internationally, be treated fairly, and afforded his freedom if no
evidence exists of wrongdoing. Mr. Kozachenko has worked tirelessly
for many years in building Ukrainian agriculture for the direct benefit
of the rural people of Ukraine.
An early resolution of these matters will keep agricultural reform and
growth on track and ensure that it remains a vital part of Ukraine's
growing private economy.
Sincerely,
MARCY KAPTUR
Member of Congress
CURT WELDON
Member of Congress
Co-Chairs, Congressional Ukrainian Caucus
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER FIVE
5-A. VOLYN 1943-1944, AN UNKNOWN TRAGEDY
The Terrible Interethnic Conflict Between Ukrainians and Poles in Volyn.
National dignity means truth for ourselves and our descendants
Prepared by Serhiy Makhun, Ihor Siundiukov,
Vyacheslav Darpinyants, and Mykhailo Mazurin
THE DAY Weekly Digest in Two Parts
Part I, May 13, 2003; Part II, May 27, 2003, Kyiv, Ukraine
Historical tragedies never disappear and are never forgotten. The terrible
interethnic conflict between Ukrainians and Poles in Volyn, which claimed
tens of thousands of human lives in 1943-1944 on two warring sides, was
hushed up in this country for decades: even in the already independent
1990s, this subject seemed to be taboo.
It is the extreme zeal with which the Polish side brought the bloody Volyn
events into focus that forced (alas, this is the right word) our leadership
to more or less adequately react to this in the year 2003. All of us,
Ukrainians and Poles alike, cannot possibly escape from the following series
of extremely difficult questions that arise over the tragedy of sixty years
ago.
Who exactly is to bear historical responsibility for a mass massacre of
people? What are the historical roots of the tragedy? Who should apologize?
What should the further course of Ukrainian-Polish relations be if
historical truth is not to fall victim to cheap political expediency?
The Day's round table on the Volyn events was special in that the answer to
these (and many other) questions was sought by people well known throughout
Ukraine, individuals whose rich lifetime experience allows them to see the
terrible events of the past through the most valuable prism, that of their
own deeply personal and inimitable perception.
The interviewees are people born and raised in that long-suffering land,
members of the Volyn fraternity, first President of Ukraine Leonid Kruchuk,
People's Deputies of Ukraine, Academician Mykola Zhulynsky, Serhiy
Shevchuk, Lieutenant General Oleksandr Skipalsky, along with
former ambassador of Ukraine to Poland and great poet Dmytro Pavlychko.
-
TO READ THE ENTIRE TEXT OF THE VOLYN 1943-1944 INTERVIEW
CLICK ON THE FOLLOWING LINK:
-
http://www.artukraine.com/historical/volyn_trag.htm
5-B. UKRAINIAN LAWMAKERS DIVIDED OVER ASSESSMENT
OF VOLYN MASSACRE IN 1943
RFE/RL NEWSLINE, Prague, Czech Republic, May 30, 2003
KYIV, Ukraine, May 30, 2003...A group of 39 Verkhovna Rada deputies
published an open letter in "Holos Ukrayiny" on 29 May to condemn the
massacre of Polish civilians by the Ukrainian Insurgent Army in Volyn in
1943 (see "RFE/RL Poland, Belarus, and Ukraine Report," 4 March 2003),
Interfax reported.
The letter criticizes alleged attempts on the part of some current
politicians to defend those who "sullied their hands with the blood of women
and children" 60 years ago as "immoral and exceptionally cynical."
Signatories included parliamentary speaker Volodymyr Lytvyn, Viktor
Musiyaka (European Choice), Nestor Shufrych (Social Democratic Party-
united), Taras Chornovil, and Yuriy Karmazin (Our Ukraine).
On 16 May, "Holos Ukrayiny" published a letter from a group of 33
predominantly right-wing lawmakers requesting that Poland abandon
the quest for "one-sided apologies" for the Volyn massacre from Ukraine.
"To achieve mutual understanding, Poland needs to revise cardinally its
anti-Ukrainian prejudices," the letter said.
That letter was signed by Hryhoriy Omelchenko, Levko Lukyanenko,
Stepan Khmara, Yaroslav Kendzyor, and Andriy Shkil, among others.
Polish and Ukrainian Presidents Aleksander Kwasniewski and Leonid
Kuchma agreed in February to organize a joint commemoration of the
massacre (see "RFE/RL Newsline," 14 February 2003). [JM]
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER SIX
6. RUSSIA'S LARGEST BREWER BALTIKA BREWERY OPENS ITS
FIRST OFFICE IN UKRAINE TO EXPAND SALES
Just-Drinks.com Editorial Team, Bromsgrove, Worcs, UK, May 30, 2003
Bromsgrove, Worcs, UK..May 30, 2003....Baltika Brewery, a Russian
company, announced the opening of its first office in Ukraine follows
similar new ventures in the former Soviet Union republics of Moldova,
Kyrgyzstan, Belarus and Kazakhstan.
The company stated such a move was designed to improve export sales.
The former Soviet republics represent a good alternative to the Russian
market, which fell 5% in the first quarter of the year. The republics have
sizable populations and a cultural affinity with Russia which assists
marketing.
The Ukrainian market, with a population of 50 million, is currently
dominated by Russia's second-largest brewer, Sun Interbrew Ltd., a unit of
Belgium's Interbrew SA. Sun Interbrew owes most of its growth in sales
volume and profit to Ukraine.
Baltika, Russia's largest brewer, is controlled by Baltic Beverage Holding,
a joint venture between Carlsberg AS and Scottish & Newcastle.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER SEVEN
7. RECONSTRUCTION OF ANCIENT CHURCH BEGINS IN KYIV
Original Church was Destroyed in 1970 During Soviet Times
Religious Information Service of Ukraine (R.I.S.U.)
Lviv, Ukraine, May 24, 2003
Lviv, Ukraine.. Archaeological and reconstruction work on the Church of
the Presentation, Ukrainian Orthodox Church-Moscow Patriarchate
(UOC-MP), was started in Kyiv's Podil neighborhood on 24 May 2003.
Archpriest Vitalii Kosovskyi, dean of Kyiv for the UOC-MP, who initiated
the restoration of this ancient church some years ago, held a prayer
service in gratitude for the beginning of the new archaeological and
reconstruction work.
A church in this location is mentioned in ancient chronicles from the times
of the baptism of Kyivan Rus in the 10th century.
The Church of the Presentation was destroyed in 1970, during Soviet times,
but now the local Orthodox community has received permission for
reconstruction. After archaeological research has been completed, the
reconstruction of the church will begin. [www.orthodox.org.ua]
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER EIGHT
8 POLISH PAINT PRODUCER HAS GOOD RESULTS
Polifarb built a production plant in Ukraine, Wants 15% of the Market
Polish News Bulletin, Warsaw, Poland, May 29, 2003
Polish News Bulletin......Polifarb Cieszyn - Wroclaw, a producer of paints,
maintained its position as market leader in 2002. The company controls over
30 percent of the paint market in Poland, its sales revenues amounted to
ZL607m and net profit was ZL14.5m.
Last year, Polifarb invested heavily to develop its distribution network and
improve customer relations. It also increased export sales, mainly to
neighbouring countries - Russia, Lithuania, Czech Republic and Ukraine.
Polifarb built a production plant in Ukraine, and hopes to gain 15 percent
of that market. In 2002, the company's export revenues grew by 2.2 percent.
During a press conference, Polifarb's president announced the company has no
plans for withdrawing from the Warsaw Stock Exchange. The call for shares,
organised in March, was due to procedural requirements - changes in the
ownership structure of Polifarb's strategic investor, the Sigma Kalon group.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER NINE
9. UKRAINIAN NEWSPAPER SAYS BRITAIN IS ON "FREE SPEECH"
BANDWAGON AGAINST UKRAINE
Ukrainian Weekly Newspaper 2000 in Russian, May 30, 2003
BBC Monitoring Service, UK, in English, May 30, 2003
The Ukrainian pro-presidential weekly 2000 has criticized a reply by the UK
minister of state for Europe, Denis MacShane, to a letter the British
National Union of Journalists, MPs and academics sent to Prime Minister
Tony Blair regarding the case of the murdered Ukrainian journalist Heorhiy
Gongadze.
The minister said it would be wrong to contemplate Ukraine's membership
of NATO or the European Union before Ukrainian journalists were given
proper protection.
The paper responded that the British government was turning a blind eye
towards cases of persecution against journalists elsewhere and accused it of
a biased attitude towards Ukraine.
-
The following is the text of the article by Oleksandr Holychev published on
30 May in Russian under the title "MacShane's demarche" and the
published by the BBC Monitoring Service, UK, in English on May 30:
-
Let's leave aside the question of what the reason for it was. In March, for
one reason or another, a group of British journalists and politicians wrote
a letter to Prime Minister Tony Blair about the investigation into the
Heorhiy Gongadze affair. Whether the authors of the message expected a reply
or simply wanted the subject of "freedom of the press in Ukraine" to stay in
the media limelight for as long as possible (it must be said once again that
the subject has already become "transnational"), the letter went unanswered
for two months - until the question of Ukraine's possible membership of the
EU and NATO was again on the agenda.
The reply to representatives of the BBC, the Sunday Telegraph, the Observer
and eight British MPs was sent not by Tony Blair himself, but by Denis
MacShane, the minister of state for Europe.
It transpires that Ukraine's main stumbling block on its way into the EU is
still "freedom of speech". According to the minister, Great Britain will not
give its blessing to our country's being integrated into European and
international structures "until Ukrainian journalists are given proper
protection". If we are to believe a report from the Interfax-Ukraine agency
on 27 May, the Gongadze affair "is still a British policy priority".
To be honest, this "priority" status is more worrying than it is surprising.
After all, the world knows of hundreds of high-profile cases involving not
just journalists, but also the highest officials of various states, yet
official London is in no hurry to include them in its policy priorities. So
you can't help wondering whether it's just a question of one isolated
journalist.
Why, for example, did the death of another Ukrainian journalist from a shot
fired by an American tank at Baghdad's Palestine Hotel (and he was not the
only one to die) not give rise to a similar reaction among British
parliamentarians?
The same applies to the arrest in Basra of a correspondent from Qatar's
Al-Jazeera TV, who was released after a stern warning and a ban on filming
"until further notice".
Moreover, during the Iraq war, the Blair government also came into conflict
with the British media when it demanded "favourable coverage of the war in
Iraq" from them, and Foreign Secretary Jack Straw even accused a section
of the British press of "a lack of patriotism that complicates the war in
Iraq".
If no British protection, let alone justice, is envisaged in such cases, how
is one to explain the latest demarche against Ukraine from the minister for
Europe, Denis MacShane? (UMRG-ARTUIS)
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER TEN
10. STUDENTS COME TO MASSACHUSETTS FROM UKRAINE
Four Ukrainian Teenagers from Buchach, a town of 14,000 in western Ukraine
By Lisa Press, Hamilton Wenham Chronicle, Townonline.com
Hamilton, Massachusetts, May 28, 2003
Hamilton, Massachusetts......In early May, four Ukrainian teenagers said
"goodbye" to their parents and traveled 12 hours from their hometown to
the capital city of Kiev, where they boarded a flight to Paris. For all
four, it was their first journey on a plane.
In Paris, they transferred onto a flight to Boston. From there, they were
escorted to homes in Hamilton and Wenham, several thousand miles from
their native country, where they spent the next month doing typical teenager
things.
For the past month, those four high school students have attended classes
and activities at the Pingree School. In addition, they had some
extracurricular fun shopping at the North Shore Mall; attending a Red Sox
game, eating pizza and Junction ice cream, making tacos, watching a film at
the Omni Theater at the Science Museum, catching a musical at the North
Shore Music Theatre; and spending a weekend in New York City.
Their visit was organized by Pingree physics teacher Eva Sacharuk, a Wenham
resident who is originally from Ukraine. She emigrated to the United States
in 1950 after her family had been detained in a "displaced persons" camp in
Austria after World War II.
Ukraine, a country in the southeastern part of Europe, bordered by Russia,
Poland, Turkey and the Black Sea, became an independent state with the
collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991. Previously, the land was known to most
as "the Ukraine," a flat fertile republic in the western Soviet Union.
The four students, all 15- and 16-year-olds, are classmates from Buchach, a town of 14,000 in western Ukraine. Sacharuk describes Buchach as a
historical town with 16th century churches and buildings, and the ruins of a
castle in the center of town.
As they experienced the routines of American life - school, carpooling,
shopping at the grocery store and eating meals - the cultural similarities
and differences became apparent. "They noticed much more discussion
in the classroom, but not as much lecturing," said Sacharuk.
Svetlana Nevistyuk, 16, said that in Ukraine her days at school are packed
with more classes, but her after-school experience is more subdued than her
new American friends. Ukrainian students take approximately 16 subjects at a
time, including English, English literature, Russian, biology, physics,
chemistry, geometry and algebra.
"Here, students go to the teacher," said Nevistyuk. "In my school in
Ukraine, the teacher comes to us. We stay in one class all day."
Nevistyuk added that unlike Americans, Ukrainian students do not participate
in an array of after-school activities and sports.
"We have a physical training class in school, and sometimes we play
basketball." In addition, Nevistyuk added that most families do not have
computers at home.
She uses the computer at school but, when she is at home, she communicates
with her friends with the telephone. There is no emailing or instant
messaging, means of communicating that have become the norm for young
people in America.
Nevistyuk and her three travel mates learned as much from their host
families as they did during the school day. Nevistyuk spent her first two
weeks with the Bishop family in Wenham, and her second two weeks with the
Riley family in Hamilton.
The Bishops, whose twins, Kyle and Drew, are in the ninth grade at the
Pingree School, took Nevistyuk to Rockport, Singing Beach and "Mame," a
musical at the North Shore Music Theatre.
Julie Bishop described Nevistyuk's first walk on a beach.
"She started walking in the sand, and had never felt that sensation before.
The sand was warm and she was just wide-eyed, like a 2-year old," said
Bishop. "She loved finding the shells, things we take for granted because
our kids have always been to the beach."
The Riley's, whose daughter, Paige, attends Pingree, also took Nevistyuk to
the beach, in addition to going on shopping trips to Newbury Street, Fanueil
Hall and the nearby malls. They also went to the Science Museum in Boston,
Woodman's of Essex and Fire and Ice, a restaurant in Boston.
Like American teenaged girls, Nevistyuk loved shopping. She bought pants for
her triplet sisters at Marshall's, and said she has loved most of the
American foods she has eaten, especially pizza, sandwiches and pasta.
Nevistyuk said she misses borscht, sauerkraut and sour milk, three foods she
eats regularly at home. She described sour milk as similar to sour cream,
only not as heavy.
However, not all American food was equally appreciated. Host families soon
learned that in Ukraine, broccoli is served only to farm animals.
The Kacoyanis family of Wenham, whose son, John, attends Pingree, hosted
Vasyl Melnyk. They took their guest to a Red Sox game, to the Science
Museum, a Chinese restaurant and miniature golfing.
"The time he showed the most emotion was at the Red Sox game," said Dr.
George Kacoyanis. That evening, Nomar Garciaparra hit a home run and Melnyk
instantly became a fan of the Sox shortstop, buying Nomar T-shirts for
himself and his niece. Kacoyanis said Melnyk also went to see the musical,
Mame.
"It was probably his first professional theater production," said Melnyk's
American host. "Where he lives in Ukraine, it is two hours to drive to a
movie or a theater, so it's a rare event to go to either. He thoroughly
enjoyed it." Kacoyanis also took Melnyk to see the recently released
action film, "The Matrix Reloaded."
"He kept his ticket stub to show all of his friends. Vasyl [Melnyk] said
that movie wouldn't open in Ukraine until the fall," said Kacoyanis.
The Ukrainian students also noticed American families drive much more than
people in their homeland, where most people walk to their destinations.
Melnyk's parents, both physicians, walk several miles to work and back each
day. "It has made me realize how hectic our lives are - by seeing it
through someone else's eyes," said Jane Riley.
"Our expectations for entertainment are so much higher. With Svetlana
[Nevistyuk], we can do something simple, like go to the Junction for ice
cream, and it's fun. Here in America, we feel we have to fill every moment,"
she added.
Kacoyanis added, "I think life in Ukraine is a little slower. Here, we're on
tight schedules." None of the three host families regretted hosting their
visitors from far away.
"We thoroughly enjoyed the experience," said Bishop. "You realize the
commonality of people throughout the world. That kids are kids and teenagers
are teenagers throughout the world."
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER ELEVEN
11. UKRAINIAN GREEK CATHOLIC RELIGIOUS LEADER CARDINAL
LUBOMYR HUSAR IN CHICAGO TO INSTALL NEW BISHOP
Ukrainian Greek Catholics in the USA greet the religious leader
By Ron Grossman, Tribune staff reporter
Chicago Tribune Online, Chicago, Illinois, May 29, 2003
With pomp, circumstance and a little old-fashioned hospitality, Ukrainian
Greek Catholics welcomed their cardinal Wednesday in the first of a series
of ceremonies that will culminate with the installation of a new bishop for
Chicago.
As Cardinal Lubomyr Husar came through the doors of St. Nicholas Cathedral,
children from the parish school dressed in traditional costume sang their
welcome to the worldwide head of their church, a lesser known form of
Catholicism but the ancestral faith of many residents of Ukrainian Village.
George Matwyshyn, president of the parish council, presented Husar with a
loaf of bread and a bit of salt, age-old symbols of welcoming a guest to a
family table.
"In the hearts of our people," Matwyshyn explained, "he is the ultimate
father of our church."
Husar came to Chicago from his headquarters in Ukraine to ordain a new
bishop at an installation service to be held Wednesday. Until the selection
of bishop-elect Richard Seminack, Chicago's Ukrainian Greek Catholics had
been without a bishop for more than two years.
Considering the scale of the eparchy, as a diocese is known in the Ukrainian
church, it is little wonder it took so long to find a suitable candidate.
Seminack's new flock is spread out over a vast territory that stretches west
from Chicago to Hawaii. It has an estimated 15,000 churchgoers, about 5,000
of whom live in or around Chicago.
Seminack, who is currently pastor of a church in Carnegie, Pa., won't arrive
in Chicago until just before his installation. Honored as he was to be
chosen for his new post, Seminack notes that it is difficult for him and his
longtime parishioners to take leave of each other.
"For 20 years, I've married them, baptized their kids and buried their
grandparents, so it's become like a family," said Seminack, 60, speaking by
phone. "For them it's sweet and sour: They're pleased to see me elevated to
bishop, sad to see me go."
Seminack will make his headquarters at St. Nicholas, in a Near West Side
neighborhood dotted with churches that mark the convoluted religious history
of the Old World homeland from which the inhabitants and their ancestors
came.
A few blocks away is St. Volodymyr Cathedral. It is an Orthodox Ukrainian
Church, whose parishioners were until recently separated from Seminack's and
Husar's followers by centuries of bitter religious antipathies. But in a new
spirit of ecumenicalism, representatives of the Orthodox Ukrainian community
are expected to participate in the festivities accompanying Seminack's
installation.
Ukrainian Village has so many churches because Ukraine sits on the
ecclesiastical fault line that, in the Middle Ages, separated Christianity
into a Western and an Eastern variety. The former centered on Rome and was
headed by the pope. Its liturgical language was Latin. The latter centered
on Constantinople (now Istanbul) and was headed by the patriarch of
Constantinople. Its liturgical language was Greek. And after the pope and
patriarch quarreled in the 11th Century, relations between the two churches
soured.
Afterward, though, some Orthodox churches, as the Eastern variety are known,
rejoined the Catholic Church. Known collectively as the Uniate churches,
they are a kind of ecclesiastical hybrid. Their worship services are Eastern
in feeling, their liturgy more mystical. But their clergy, like Cardinal
Husar, report to the Holy See at Rome.
The largest of those Uniate Churches is the Ukrainian Greek Catholic, which
Husar estimates to have more than 3 million adherents in Ukraine. The
Ukrainian Orthodox Church has an estimated three times as many members.
In the 16th Century, parts of Ukraine came under the rule of the king of
Poland who, as a Catholic, sponsored the reunion of his Orthodox bishops and
priests with Rome. The name "Ukrainian Greek" is said to stem from another
historical accident, reports Matwyshyn.
"In the 18th Century, the Hapsburg ruler Maria Teresa had Ukrainian
Catholics among her subjects," Matwyshyn said. "She knew we stemmed
from the Greek church, so she called us `Greek Catholics.'"
After World War II, the Soviet Union took over parts of western Ukraine and
tried to extinguish the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, noted Husar, who
was born there but was brought to America where his parents took refuge from
totalitarianism in the 1949. Priests were forced to swear a new allegiance
to the Russian Orthodox Church, of whose loyalty Stalin felt more assured.
Clergy who refused were sent to Siberia. Others went underground--in a rerun
of early Christianity's catacombs days--until its legality was restored
after the fall of communism in the late 1980s.
"Our church survived because people knew they could find a priest when they
needed him to perform a marriage ceremony in secret," said Husar. "It shows
you not just how strong their faith was, but also a facet of human nature:
If you say people can't do something, it inspires them with the resolve to
do it anyway." (UMRG-ARTUIS)
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER TWELVE
12. MOSCOW EXHIBIT CELEBRATES A SOVIET-ERA INTELLIGENCE
AGENCY SMERSH, "DEATH TO SPIES," RUTHLESS IN UKRAINE
SMERSH fought the Ukrainian Nationalist Movement. SMERSH "acted
very ruthlessly" in Ukraine, sometimes destroying villages that had helped
the nationalists and sending the entire surviving populations to Siberia
By David Holley, Staff Writer for the Los Angeles Times
Los Angeles Times, Los Angeles, California, May 25, 2003
MOSCOW -- In Ian Fleming's early James Bond novels, villains like Dr. No
and Goldfinger worked for SMERSH, a diabolical Soviet intelligence agency.
Readers could believe the organization was a real part of the KGB, or they
might assume it was fictional -- particularly because it bore such a
deliciously evil-sounding name.
SMERSH -- short for Smert Shpionam, or "Death to Spies" -- was real enough,
right down to the spooky name. But it existed only for three years, and
predated the KGB, according to a special Moscow museum exhibit celebrating
the 60th anniversary of its birth. As portrayed in the displays and by
guides, it had a glorious history outwitting Nazi intelligence during World
War II.
Organized at the initiative of the agency's elderly veterans, the exhibit
contains nothing to offend them. It received favorable coverage in Russian
media, including nationwide television news. Its very existence reflects an
increasingly tolerant view of the hard-nosed intelligence organizations that
once inflicted terror and political suppression -- but also a degree of
discipline -- on Soviet society.
This is, after all, a country whose highly popular president started out as
a career KGB man and later headed the Federal Security Service, or FSB, the
domestic successor to the Soviet-era KGB. After the tumultuous upheavals and
rampant corruption that followed the fall of communism, many Russians think
that maybe the old days of enforced order weren't so bad after all.
Also, it is easy to portray SMERSH as a more noble and patriotic
organization than either its predecessor or successor agencies.
According to the exhibit and Russian scholars, SMERSH -- formed from a
security and counterintelligence directorate within the notorious NKVD
secret police -- existed under its own name only from April 19, 1943, until
May 1946, a period of Soviet military glory.
"They're celebrating SMERSH deliberately," said Sergei Kozhin, head
researcher at the Russian Armed Forces Museum, which is presenting the
exhibit through the end of May. "That's a way to distance ourselves from the
political terror that was happening in the Soviet Union before World War II
and after World War II. The idea of this exhibit is to commemorate those
people who were fighting against fascism during the years of the war."
About 7,000 SMERSH agents were officially listed as killed in the war,
primarily in combat operations, and an additional 4,000 missing were
presumed dead, Kozhin said.
While the exhibit projects an impression of nonideological objectivity mixed
with patriotic fervor, critics say that it ignores SMERSH's darker role in
terrorizing citizens viewed as enemies of the Soviet state.
"SMERSH was not controlled effectively by anyone, and they could do whatever
they wanted," said Vadim Telitsyn, a scholar at the Institute of Russian
History, who wrote a book about the agency. "They could arrest anybody of
their own free will, from a simple peasant to an authority figure. The word
'SMERSH' terrified even Soviet officers who had fought the war."
The name "Death to Spies" was personally chosen by Soviet dictator Joseph
Stalin, Telitsyn said. "One of the leaders suggested it should be called,
'Death to German Spies,' " he said. "But Stalin logically replied, 'Why only
German spies?' "
Whatever its shortcomings, the exhibit still opens a fascinating window on a
once-secretive slice of Soviet history that through Ian Fleming and Bond now
has a place in Western pop culture.
Most of all, the displays celebrate SMERSH's "radio games" against the
Nazis' Abwehr military intelligence service, which Kozhin said parachuted
thousands of agents behind Russian lines. Items they were said to have used,
such as a cigarette bearing a coded message, are on display.
"At the beginning of the war, German spies who were caught were as a rule
shot on the spot," Kozhin said. "That was a big mistake." SMERSH soon
realized that it could use captured spies to lure more spies into traps, he
said.
"The captured German agents were forced to take part in these radio games,"
Kozhin said. "It was a game because these agents or double agents would be
sending messages to their headquarters as if they were at large, like
they're expecting new paratroopers to land, money and weapons. It was really
a game for SMERSH because the Germans usually fell for these tricks and
would send all that was requested -- but SMERSH would be the final
destination."
Captured agents also sent false reports back to their headquarters,
claiming, for example, that the Russians were preparing an offensive in one
sector while the attack was really to come elsewhere.
Also on display are documents relating to the discovery of Hitler's remains
in his Berlin bunker and the destruction of all but a few key fragments.
Fragments of Hitler's jaw and a piece of his skull were sent to Moscow,
Kozhin said. But the rest of his remains, according to the exhibit and
Kozhin, were taken by SMERSH and held in East Germany by the agency
or its successors until 1970, when the Politburo authorized then-KGB
Director Yuri Andropov to carry out their destruction.
The remains were burned in a field, ground to powder and thrown in a river,
according to the exhibit. The jaw fragments are kept in the FSB's central
archive, and the piece of skull, bearing a bullet hole, is stored at the
Central State Archive of Russia, Kozhin said, and is not part of the
exhibit.
The exhibit also praises SMERSH's role in fighting a Ukrainian nationalist
movement that Kozhin said was not defeated by Soviet armed forces until
1954. "Ukrainian nationalists managed to kill about 30,000 Soviet
administrators and party members, but they themselves lost about 100,000
people in the battles with the Red Army," he said.
On display, labeled as items used by Ukrainian nationalists, are devices
that could do James Bond proud: a pen that could fire a bullet, a finger
ring with a special compartment for invisible ink, and a comb broken in half
that could be matched up by two agents, each carrying one piece, to confirm
each other's identity.
Anyone sympathetic to Ukrainian nationalism -- or even balanced history --
might well be angered by this part of the exhibit. Telitsyn, the history
scholar, said that SMERSH "acted very ruthlessly" in Ukraine, sometimes
destroying villages that had helped the nationalists and sending the entire
surviving populations to Siberia.
SMERSH used "terrorist methods" such as poison and bombs to kill
Ukrainian nationalist leaders in German and Austrian exile, he said,
adding, "I don't think the exhibit tells anything about that."
He also criticized its failure to touch on the mistreatment by SMERSH of
returned Russian prisoners of war, who were often treated as suspected
spies.
SMERSH was also responsible for carrying on a practice begun early in the
war, when special "stop-retreat" units were placed immediately behind the
Russian front lines with orders to shoot any soldiers who tried to run from
battle, Telitsyn said.
During the Soviet era, "this entire story around SMERSH and state security
was not available to the public," Kozhin said. "Everything was secret. And
the attitude toward state security bodies in this country was very negative
for the first 10 years of Russia being a democratic state."
But now "democracy has degenerated into anarchy," with the result that
"society is less critical about the former regime in general, and its
leaders as well," he said. (UMRG-ARTUIS)
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51: ARTICLE NUMBER THIRTEEN
13. UK CHARTER FIRM IN AIR CRASH ROW
Firm Brokered Hiring of Aircraft Belonging to Ukrainian Mediterranean
Airlines. V. Gorbanovskyi, deputy director of UM Air, defends airplane.
One passenger called home and said, "Pray for me, this airplane is shit"
By Giles Tremlett in Madrid, and David Pallister in London
The Guardian Newspaper Online, London, UK, Friday, May 30, 2003
LONDON, A British company found itself in the middle of a row about how
NATO charters civilian aircraft yesterday, as controversy grew over the
deaths of 62 Spanish peacekeepers in an aircrash.
Chapman Freeborn, a London charter firm with offices in 19 countries,
brokered the hiring of the Yak-42D aircraft belonging to Ukrainian
Mediterranean Airlines (UM Air) that crashed into a mountain near the
northern Turkish city of Trabzon in fog.
Chapman Freeborn had been contacted by NATO's maintenance and supply
agency to supply an aircraft for the trip from Kabul in Afghanistan to
Spain. Spanish newspapers have reported that peacekeepers boarding the
aircraft were so concerned that one, Commander Fernandez Martinez, rang
home and told his wife: "Pray for me, this airplane is shit."
The prime minister, Jose Maria Aznar, and defence minister, Federico Trillo,
were booed and called assassins by relatives when the coffins arrived at a
Madrid air base on Wednesday. Lord Robertson, Nato secretary general,
visiting Spain yesterday, declared: "Nobody was cutting corners, nobody was
trying to do it on the cheap, nobody was putting lives at risk."
The Norwegian and Finnish defence ministries, however, admitted they had
stopped using UM Air. "We take safety seriously, and that's why we stopped,"
a Norwegian military spokesman said.
"The type [Yak-42D] was not instrumental in our decision to cancel the
contract, but rather the level of maintenance the company showed," said a
Finnish spokesman, Lieutenant-Colonel Kimmo Salomaa. He added that few
other companies were willing to fly to Afghanistan.
Volodymyr Gorbanovskyi, deputy director of UM Air, said the 15-year-old
plane's navigation, communications, and safety systems had been renovated in
June 2001 and a further check was made last month.
"It was not just a cosmetic upgrade, but a full technical modernisation to
European standards," he told the Associated Press.
Ukraine's transport ministry, however, has publicly alleged "serious
violations" in UM Air's certification, licensing, and reporting procedures -
though a spokeswoman for its air transport department later said the
ministry's information had been wrong. Mr Gorbanovskyi also denied
these allegations.
A spokeswoman for Chapman Freeborn confirmed yesterday that the
company's Frankfurt office had chartered the Yak-42 for Nato and said
it had used the airline before.
But she declined to comment on the details of the charter. "That is a matter
for Nato," she said. "But when we charter a plane we always do a thorough
check for insurance and safety reasons."
An MoD spokeswoman said yesterday it used 10 charter brokers but chartered
only "EU- or US-registered airlines" for transporting people.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 51, WEEKEND EDITION, May 31-June 1, 2003
"The Art of Ukrainian History, Culture, Arts, Business, Religion,
Sports, Government, and Politics, in Ukraine and Around the World"
THIRTEEN ARTICLES
FOR PERSONAL AND ACADEMIC USE ONLY
|
|