|
Ukraine Report 2003, No. 2 ArtUkraine.com Information Service
Kyiv, Ukraine and Washington, D.C.
Monday, February 10, 2003
INDEX OF STORIES:
1. U.S. AMBASSADOR PASCUAL OUTLINES STEPS FOR
IMPROVING U.S.-UKRAINIAN RELATIONS, By Tim Vickery
Associated Press Writer, Kyiv, Ukraine, Thursday, February 6, 2003
2. TO VISIT SILENCE, To visit Chernobyl is to visit silence.
The city of Prypiat remains a ghost town. By Natalia A. Feduschak
The Washington, Times, Washington, D.C., Sunday, February 9, 2003
3. CONG. WELDON INDULGES PASSION FOR RUSSIA AMID
GRUMBLES, By Peter Nicholas, Inquirer Washington Bureau
Philadelphia Inquirer, February 9, 2003
4. UKRAINIAN ASYLUM-SEEKER IN BRITIAN COMMITS
SUICIDE, SUICIDE AT REFUGEE CENTRE SPARKS HUNGER
STRIKE, Mikhail Bodnarchuk was due to be deported back to Ukraine
the day after he killed himself. By Sophie Goodchild, Home Affairs
Correspondent, Independent Digital, London, UK, 09 February 2003
5. WHAT'S THE POLICY TOWARD UKRAINE? by Andrew
Fedynsky, PERSPECTIVES (Op-Ed), The Ukrainian Weekly
Parsippany, New Jersey, February 2, 2003
6. YUSHCHENKO: UKRAINE HAS TO FIND WAY TO
DEMOCRACY, Yushchenko in Washington, By E. Morgan Williams,
ArtUkraine.com, Washington, D.C., Friday, February 7, 2003
7. VOA MAKES SUBSTANTIAL CUTS IN PROGRAM TO
UKRAINE, 10 Eastern Europe Broadcasts To End, By Olga
Dryzhanovska, The Washington Times, Washington, D.C., Feb. 7, 2003
8. UKRAINE AND BELARUS, THOSE EASTERN SLAVS
FARCICAL PERFORMANCE, It is a bizarre performance to watch
Editorial, By The Baltic Times, Riga, Lativa, February 06, 2003
9. RUSSIA TAKES CONTROL OF CONTROVERSIAL ARMENIAN
NUCLEAR PLANT, "Built to the same design as the Chernobyl atomic
power station in Ukraine." "It also follows a trend in other ex-Soviet
republics, such as Ukraine, where Russian investors have aggressively
snatched up banks, a broadcaster and oil refineries." By David Stern in
Moscow, Financial Times, London, England, UK, February 08, 2003
10. CRACKDOWN ON ILLEGAL FERTILITY TREATMENT TRADE
Couples may also be attracted by the cheaper cost of fertility treatment in
Russia, the Ukraine, India and Greece. By Sarah-Kate Templeton, Health
Editor, Sunday Herald, Glasgow, UK, Sunday, February 9, 2003
11. MICROSOFT RESPONDS TO CRITICISMS THAT NEW
UKRAINIAN SOFTWARE USES "SURZHYK," By Roman Woronowycz,
The Ukrainian Weekly, January 19, 2003
12. UKRAINIAN SPRINTERS BLOCK AND DOVGAL WIN IN EUROPE
Ukraine's Zhanna Block Wins 60 Meter Dash At Flanders, Ukrainian Sprinter
Anatoliy Dovgal Wins In Budapest, ArtUkraine.com; A/P; and IAAF,
February 9, 2003
13. U.S. OFFICIAL ILLEGALLY SOLD VISAS ABROAD
In January 2000, he met with a Ukrainian "broker" in a Prague beer hall.
Once the forms were processed, Meerovich would approve the visas without
interviewing the applicants -- most often Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians,
By Neely Tucker, Washington Post Staff Writer, The Washington Post,
Washington, D.C., Saturday, February 8, 2003; Page A03
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER ONE
1. U.S. AMBASSADOR PASCUAL OUTLINES STEPS FOR IMPROVING
U.S.-UKRAINIAN RELATIONS
By Tim Vickery, Associated Press Writer
Kyiv, Ukraine, Thursday, February 6, 2003
KIEV, Ukraine - U.S. Ambassador Carlos Pascual urged Ukraine on Thursday to
stop meddling in the media, tighten export controls and strengthen
anti-money laundering regulations to improve deeply strained bilateral ties.
Pascual made the recommendations as he announced planned cuts in financial
assistance to Ukraine after a "comprehensive policy review" that put Ukraine among other former Soviet countries that had become less dependent on
monetary aid.
He stressed that the United States would continue to provide money to help
Ukraine improve media freedoms, develop civil society, and improve border
controls.
"If Ukraine is willing to move forward on these (reforms), it can result in
positive, concrete, constructive developments ... and improve confidence
between our two countries," Pascual said.
The Bush administration has asked Congress to reduce 2003 aid to Ukraine by
US$15 million and US$46 million in 2004. Ukraine received some $US155
million last year, making it one of the top recipients of U.S. foreign aid
worldwide.
The policy review was launched last year after Washington said it had
authenticated audio recordings in which President Leonid Kuchma is heard
approving the sale of sophisticated radar systems to Baghdad. Kuchma denies
the charges, which caused the worst crisis in ties with the West since
Ukraine's independence in 1991.
Pascual also said it was "extremely important" for Ukraine to demonstrate it
was a "responsible partner" in fighting terrorism by beefing up export and
border controls to prevent leakages of military technologies and equipment.
Another "obvious step" Pascual suggested Ukraine take to regain credibility
was for officials to stop instructing the press on what to report.
"What we're all hoping for is an environment where representatives of the
press really feel that they can pursue the truth ... and that they will not
be under threat as a result," he said.
Pascual praised Ukraine's recent efforts to strengthen laws against
money-laundering but said more was needed before Washington would support
removal of sanctions recommended by the Paris-based Financial Action Task
Force, or FATF.
Ukraine's Parliament adopted amendments to banking laws aimed to prevent
financial institutions from laundering money and reducing the threshold for
monitoring suspicious transactions, the Interfax news agency reported.
FATF plans to review Ukraine's performance Feb. 12. Even if the tougher laws
meet international standards, FATF says Ukraine must enforce them before
fully normalizing its status.
Pascual appeared optimistic about the future of U.S.-Ukraine relations based
on a "broad relationship at various levels with the government," implying
that Washington was looking beyond Kuchma to other officials.
Kuchma said in December that Ukraine's damaged relations with the United
States was his biggest political problem and ending it would be his main
challenge in 2003. (tv/dgs/ee)
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER TWO
2. TO VISIT SILENCE
To visit Chernobyl is to visit silence.
The city of Prypiat remains a ghost town.
By Natalia A. Feduschak
The Washington, Times
Washington, D.C.
Sunday, February 9, 2003
PRYPIAT, Ukraine - The changes during the past five years at the
Chernobyl nuclear power station are evident from the rooftop of a 13-story
apartment building about a mile away. Top Stories
The sarcophagus of its No. 4 reactor, the one that blew in 1986, looks
sturdier than before, thanks to $300 million in upgrades. Plans are under
way to permanently encase the structure to make certain the tiny cracks that
developed on the hastily built original container don't let water in and
start chemical reactions inside, perhaps causing another explosion.
Crews from France and Italy work in an adjacent field that will be the
burial ground for the radioactive waste, which cannot be transported outside
Chernobyl's "dead zone," the circle extending nearly 10 miles in all
directions that received the most radioactive fallout.
The station's elongated administration building, site of a freak fire
in 1993, is now painted a glaring white. The meandering Prypiat River that
runs alongside the station is finally showing signs of life - the occasional
tracks of a mouse, hawk or fox on its banks.
Some things, however, haven't changed. The majestic green forest that
spreads out like a delta into neighboring Belarus is deceiving. The forest
is contaminated. In some spots, radiation reaches hundreds of times the
normal background level.
The city of Prypiat, abandoned within hours of the 1986 explosion,
remains a ghost town. Walls of a spacious kindergarten are still adorned by
pictures drawn in a child's hand, while crumbling apartment blocks contain
stoves, sofas and mattresses.
"Eventually this place will be swallowed by the earth," a guide tells
his visitor as they trample through Prypiat's soccer field, inaugurated days
before the accident and now overgrown with birch trees. "You know what
the Bible says: 'Ashes to ashes, dust to dust.' "
A Kiev tourist agency offers tours to Chernobyl for people interested
in "extreme eco-tourism." The daylong trip costs $193 for an individual,
less per person for groups. To visit Chernobyl is to visit silence.
Ukraine decided to open the grounds around the station to tourists to
teach them about the accident and to disseminate information about the
challenges it faces.
"There is so much misinformation," said Mykola Dmytruk, assistant
director of Chernobyl's information agency, Chernobylinform. "Trips like
these are one way of combating it."
Tourist visits don't add much to the station's budget; last year, tours
brought in about $3,000 after costs. Still, visitors are able to see the
site and get a good look at the No. 4 reactor from a safe vantage point.
Taking pictures up close isn't allowed to ensure terrorists can't study the
station's security features.
Visitors also see the abandoned town of Prypiat, and, as a Geiger
counter clicks rapidly, drive quickly past areas with elevated levels of
radiation to visit the machinery graveyard. There, helicopters, trucks and
cars used in the 1986 evacuation effort rust away. A private company sells
approved vehicles as scrap metal. Only those with special permission can go
inside the station.
In addition, visitors can visit with elderly residents who were
evacuated from their homes but returned illegally over the years to take up
gardening and raising pigs for food in the dead zone.
The station's most frequent visitors are scientists, teachers and
journalists.
Chernobyl's most pressing problem today is lack of finances, said Mr.
Dmytruk, of Chernobylinform.
Since the station closed its last operating reactor two years ago under
international pressure, Ukraine has lost nearly $920,000 a day in energy
exports. In addition, the country has received only a fraction of the nearly
$1 billion in aid promised by the international community to offset those
losses and finish building two other Ukrainian nuclear power stations, Mr.
Dmytruk said.
"Because of that," he said, there is a strong feeling here the station
should be restarted. "We all know that won't happen; it would be politically
inappropriate. But there is disillusionment with the West."
Although foreign donors have been diligent in ensuring that a permanent
structure is built over the No. 4 reactor's sarcophagus, Mr. Dmytruk and his
colleagues are more worried about the area around the station. The
contaminated forests are prone to fires in dry seasons, which could send
their radiation to points farther west, but there is scant money for upkeep.
Water from the Prypiat River flows into the Dnipro River and then into the
Black Sea.
A major challenge has been to ensure that radioactivity from the
station doesn't wander south.
There are other pressing issues: re-educating workers who will lose
their jobs as the station shuts down, monitoring the health of the those
working at Chernobyl and paying the electric bill.
"Just because you shut the station down doesn't mean it stops
functioning," Mr. Dmytruk said. "It is a living organism."
Recently, the Kiev-based company that provides electricity to
Chernobyl - one of its partners is an American - threatened to cut off
energy because of debt. That is troubling, Mr. Dmytruk said, because even
though the station doesn't generate electricity, the nuclear reactors have
to be cooled.
"Can you imagine cutting electricity to a nuclear power station?" he
asked.
Though the Ukrainian government annually budgets funds for Chernobyl,
the station has been getting less and less money. The situation has become
so critical that Ukraine's new prime minister, Victor Yanukovych, made an
emergency visit to the station to meet with directors shortly after taking
office. He promised more money.
Such promises mean little to the guards who man the security checkpoint
on the road leading to the village of Paryshiv, which is home to 36 persons,
mostly widows, who returned to their homes after being evacuated by Soviet
authorities immediately after the disaster.
On a recent evening, the guards manning the checkpoint sat in a dark
booth. Later, one of them, who did not want to be named, acknowledged that
he and his colleagues had been without electricity for five days.
That doesn't keep the wolves at bay, he joked.
Mikhail and Maria Urypa come out their front gate to greet another
visitor from abroad. They've been married for 46 years and have been through
this before. In the past week they had answered questions from
correspondents from HBO and a Brazilian reporter about why they decided to
return to their home days after the Chernobyl accident.
The childhood sweethearts made clear why they refused to leave:
Chernobyl is their birthright. They may live in a ghost town, but at least
they will be buried next to their ancestors.
The Urypa homestead is simple: a house, a barn, a summer kitchen. What
concerns Mrs. Urypa most now is how she will get milk now that her oldest
cow has died.
"It's gotten bad in the last two months," she said as her husband
insisted on entertaining his reluctant guests with home brew.
"Usually the authorities would come here to pay our pensions, bring
groceries by truck and take us into town so we could buy clothes and other
things. But they have stopped coming. I can't live without milk."
Mrs. Urypa operates the only ham radio in town, the lifeline of
residents to the outside world. If someone gets sick, Mrs. Urypa calls
Chernobyl authorities. If someone disappears, as one elderly neighbor did
not long ago, she calls authorities.
"Come visit us again," Mrs. Urypa said, as she posed for a photo with
her new, year-old heifer.
The consequences for Ukraine of the Chernobyl nuclear disaster will
remain for generations. Although only a few dozen exposed people died soon
after the accident, tens of thousands of cancer deaths are expected,
Ukrainian doctors said.
"We are only now beginning to see the after effects," said Yevgheniya
Stepanova, a physician from Ukraine's Academy of Medical Sciences who has
been studying children affected by the Chernobyl accident. Children born
during or shortly after the explosion will soon have children of their own.
"Only then will we have a better idea of the long-term effects of
radiation," she said.
Meanwhile, in the most contaminated regions of the country, an alarming
number of babies with Down syndrome are being born to young women.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER THREE
Ukraine is not mentioned in this story about the main interests of
Cong. Curt Weldon of Pennsylvania.
3. CONG. WELDON INDULGES PASSION FOR RUSSIA AMID GRUMBLES
By Peter Nicholas
Inquirer Washington Bureau
Philadelphia Inquirer
February 9, 2003
U.S. Rep. Curt Weldon, a Delaware County Republican, has a plan to bolster
the middle class.
Russia's middle class.
Weldon minds his casework, too. Right now, he's helping a young man
who was hit by a car five years ago and paralyzed from the chest down.
The only difference is the victim is Russian and the collision took place in
Vladivostok. Smitten with the former Soviet Union since college, Weldon,
55, at times seems to have turned his congressional office into a one-man
version of the State Department's Russia desk.
He has visited Russia and other former Soviet republics 30 times in his
life - twice since Thanksgiving. He is on a first-name basis with members
of the Duma, the counterpart to the House of Representatives.
A self-made freelance diplomat without portfolio, he bounces from Moldova
to Belarus, Georgia to Uzbekistan - setting up softball games with members
of Congress, addressing parliaments in weekend sessions specially arranged
for his visit, pushing bilateral accords that reflect his own vision of
what the U.S.-Russian relationship ought to be.
There are no votes for Weldon to pick up in Russia. But the East is giving
this Russian studies major from West Chester University a measure of
recognition that he can't get back home.
"Whenever I go, I'm on Russian TV all the time," Weldon said in an
interview in his congressional office.
Last year, Weldon was inducted into the Russian Academy of Social Sciences.
In his office, he shows a visitor mementos from the ceremony: a picture of
himself in cap and gown, along with his official academy ID card.
"From mayor of Marcus Hook to the Russian Academy of Sciences," said
Weldon, a senior member of the House Armed Services Committee first
elected to Congress in 1986.
The taxpayer-funded trips aren't cheap. In 2001, Weldon led a six-member
delegation to Russia. The Navy C-9 plane trip alone cost nearly $30,000.
In Pennsylvania's Seventh Congressional District, Weldon's critics are
puzzled by his fascination with Russia, wondering what any of it has to do
with his constituents.
"In an opportunistic way, he seems to try to muscle his way into things
that are high-visibility at the moment," said David Landau, a local
Democratic Party official and Weldon's opponent in the 1988 campaign. "It
doesn't seem part of any congressional or officially sanctioned effort.
It's, 'I'm Curt Weldon and I want to get into this debate.' "
The executive branch also has worried about Weldon's forays, wincing at his
penchant for leaping into diplomatic muddles and meeting with mysterious
characters in hopes of brokering agreements that have eluded the pros at
the State Department. A Bush administration foreign-policy insider
describes Weldon as a "well-intentioned dabbler" when it comes to Russia.
In recent weeks, Weldon has sought unsuccessfully to get into North Korea,
in hopes of opening a dialogue the White House has shunned.
None of the criticism particularly troubles Weldon, who holds the safest of
seats. He sees himself as a member of a coequal branch of government eager
to spare the nation bloody, expensive wars. If the diplomatic set doesn't
like his style, so what?
"State Department people come and go... . When the [Russian] Academy of
Sciences chose to put someone in the academy, they didn't pick our
ambassador," Weldon said. "They didn't pick someone back here from the
State Department. They picked me. So I don't have to worry about what the
State Department thinks.
"I know what I'm doing is the right thing and is connecting with the
Russians."
If he doesn't like the direction of the Bush administration's Russia
policy, Weldon won't let party loyalties keep him from giving a very public
nudge.
In 2001, he sought to broaden talks between Bush and Russian leader
Vladimir V. Putin at a summit in Washington and Crawford, Texas. In a bid
to shift the discussion from security matters to a range of issues
including health care and energy policy, Weldon gave the two leaders a
44-page call for a better U.S.-Russian relationship, titled "A New Time; A
New Beginning."
Still, most of the publicity following the summit centered on arms control.
Weldon has met some odd characters on the international stage. Such
meetings can be touchy, with the congressman at risk of being used.
In December, he had a long dinner with the leader of Belarus, Alexander G.
Lukashenko, described by critics as Europe's last dictator. After the
meeting, Lukashenko put out a news release saying that Weldon's delegation
had endorsed his leadership. "Outrageous lies," Weldon countered at the
time.
Back in Delaware County, some of Weldon's constituents ask about the
relevance of the congressman's adventures to their own lives.
Told of Weldon's interest in Russia, Dave Coulter, clearing snow off his
car on a recent afternoon in Marcus Hook, said: "I'd like to see him
spending more time on needs back here. He's only spending taxpayer money."
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2, STORY NUMBER FOUR
4. UKRAINIAN ASYLUM-SEEKER IN BRITAIN COMMITS SUICIDE
SUICIDE AT REFUGEE CENTRE SPARKS HUNGER STRIKE
Mikhail Bodnarchuk was due to be deported back to Ukraine the day after
he killed himself. "People are shocked and devastated," said a source who
was unwilling to be named.
"He was fleeing persecution, and chose to take his own life rather than
allow his tormentors to take it for him."
By Sophie Goodchild
Home Affairs Correspondent
Independent Digital, London, UK
09 February 2003
An official inquiry has been launched into the death of an asylum-seeker,
found hanged by his shoelaces in a detention centre. Mikhail Bodnarchuk
was due to be deported back to Ukraine the day after he killed himself.
The suicide of Mr Bodnarchuk has alarmed campaigners who believe that
the Government's determination to detain more refugees and deport them
more quickly will lead to more deaths.
A week after Mr Bodnarchuk's body was found hanging from the ceiling
of a washroom at Haslar removal centre in Gosport, Hampshire, a second
man, understood to be from Africa, is in a critical condition in hospital
after he also tried to hang himself on Friday.
The death of Mr Bodnarchuk, 42, a former soldier, has prompted a hunger
strike in protest at conditions at the centre. Inmates are strip-searched on
arrival, issued with a uniform and held behind locked security doors.
More than 1,800 asylum-seekers are currently locked up in detention
centres in the UK and denied access to bail even though they have
committed no crime.
The Home Affairs Select Committee is investigating the issue of self-harm
and suicide in detention centres as part of an official inquiry into asylum
removals.
Rosy Bremer, from Bail for Immigration Detainees (BID), said the extreme
psychological distress of many asylum-seekers was exacerbated by their
treatment in Britain. "In the Government's mind, asylum-seekers are almost
non-human," she said.
One former Haslar detainee said: "I saw fellow asylum-seekers going
clinically insane, attempting suicide. You would think these scenes would
trigger human rights probes but not when it is 'only' asylum-seekers."
The Institute of Race Relations has recorded at least three suicides at UK
detention centres. At Haslar, there have been at least four attempted
suicides over the past three years. Detainees said they were too afraid to
speak out about their treatment.
Mr Bodnarchuk came to Britain in September 2000, leaving behind his wife
and two children. Immigration officials mistakenly accused him of claiming
asylum under two identities. His claim was turned down and he was served
a deportation order.
"People are shocked and devastated," said a source who was unwilling to
be named.
"He was fleeing persecution, and chose to take his own life rather than
allow his tormentors to take it for him."
Independent Digital, London, United Kingdom
Letters: letters@independent.co.uk
News Desk: newseditor@independent.co.uk
Foreign Desk: foreigneditor@independent.co.uk
http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/this_britain/story.jsp?story=376724
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER FIVE
5. WHAT'S THE POLICY TOWARD UKRAINE?
by Andrew Fedynsky
PERSPECTIVES (Op-Ed)
The Ukrainian Weekly
Ukrainian National Association
Parsippany, New Jersey
February 2, 2003
The 20th Century was rough on Ukrainians in a way that's impossible to
fathom: during both world wars, Ukraine served as a battlefield for years
on end. Afterwards there were revolutionary struggles of appalling cruelty.
Factor in the Man-made Famine of 1932-33, the Great Terror, Chornobyl,
totalitarianism, mass emigration, etc. Weighed against all that, you might
say that Ukraine in 2003 has never been in better shape:
- Ukrainians can worship God in whatever form they choose.
- Ukraine is a democracy.
- People respect Ukraine's national symbols.
- National leaders speak Ukrainian.
- Minority languages and cultures are flourishing.
- Ukraine's economy is making slow but steady progress.
- Independent civic, social and cultural groups are creating a civil
society.
Despite all this, there's no denying that Ukraine has serious problems, not
the least of which is growing isolation, illustrated dramatically at the
NATO summit in November when President Bush made a point of snubbing
President Kuchma and encouraged other leaders to do the same. Most did.
Poland's Kwasniewsky and Italy's Berlusconi, reportedly, were exceptions.
Critics contend that Kuchma himself brought this isolation on Ukraine.
Citing credible accusations of corruption, abuse of office, election
tampering, the illegal sale of military equipment to Iraq, even complicity
in murder, Ukraine's leader to them conveys more the image of gangster than
president.
Without excusing any shortcomings, others see a double standard, pointing to
Russia's links to the "Axis of Evil" (Iran, Iraq and Korea.) Russia is
building six nuclear reactors in Iran, a project the Bush administration
fears will lead to an Iranian nuclear bomb. Ironically, this is the same
project that Ukraine abandoned at the request of the Clinton administration
because of those very same fears. Heedless of America's concerns, Russia
stepped in and picked up the contract.
Russia also maintains a close relationship with Iraq, negotiating huge deals
and protecting Saddam Hussein's access to radio jammers and intercepts,
global positioning equipment, high speed computers, antidotes for nerve
agents and other items with dual civilian-military applications.
Russia is also cozy with the world's most recent nuclear threat, North
Korea, whose dictator, Kim Jong Il, visited Moscow twice in the past two
years.
Then there's the frightful campaign against the Chechens, which spares
neither civilians nor combatants. President Putin responded to human rights
protests by expelling monitors and journalists. He's also getting rid of
Roman Catholic priests, labor organizers, Peace Corps volunteers and others
who complicate things by speaking the truth and acting freely.
Despite all this, President Bush extolled Mr. Putin for having a "good
soul," hosted him at his ranch and, after snubbing Kuchma in Prague, flew
to St. Petersburg to assuage any concerns the Russian president might have
about NATO expansion.
By any fair measure, Ukraine does suffer from a double standard. Why? A
good part of it, I think, involves the tremendous stature of Russian
culture. Consider the composers: Tchaikowksy, Rachmaninov,
Rimsky-Korsakov, Shostakovych; novelists: Dostoevsky, Tolstoy, Bulgakov,
Solzhenitsyn. Think of the Kirov Ballet, the Hermitage in St. Petersburg or
Russian architecture. Indeed, Ivan the Terrible was so pleased with the
work of one architect that he ordered him blinded so he couldn't design
anything as beautiful again. Centuries later in 1944, when cinematographer
Sergei Eisenstein filmed Ivan the Terrible, people understood: Joseph
Stalin.
And that's the underside of Russian culture, something many people in the
West discount. They adore the Bolshoi Ballet while accepting the
ghastliness of figures like Lenin, Dzerzhinsky and Andropov. Even those who
are appalled by Putin's Chechen policies, respect Russia's nuclear arsenal
and veto power in the UN Security Council.
Ukraine, whose culture is barely known in the West, does not get the benefit
of the doubt that Russia does. Ever since the 1930s, when Stalin massacred
the artists and audiences that were creating a Ukrainian renaissance, the
country has been in the shadows-a bit of a joke, a bit of an
embarrassment-holding a seat in the United Nations, but voting exactly as
the Kremlin ordered. With the exception of Ukrainians themselves, the world
greeted independence as a huge surprise. Since then, Ukraine has made
visible progress, but resistance from those who are vested in the past is
keeping the country's democracy from really taking off. And it's leading to
isolation.
Those pointing at Russia and arguing that Ukraine is subject to
a double standard are right, of course, but lowering our expectations to the
level that many accept for Russia is not the answer. Russia's in another
league. Besides, Ukrainian independence is based on rejection of the
Russian model. That's a goal the whole world can support. Certainly
friends like Poland and Lithuania-countries that Russia once dominated-want
Ukraine to succeed.
Today, many forces in Ukraine are working toward positive change. Most have
some kind of link to America and, of course, there are several treaties that
bind our two countries together, especially the one where Ukraine agreed to
dismantle the third largest nuclear arsenal in existence: no small gesture.
The tools are there to continue building Ukraine's democracy, but American
support remains critical.
During the Clinton administration, Ukrainian-American leaders-both
Republicans and Democrats-met regularly with the national security team,
including the president and vice president themselves, to consult about
America's policy toward Ukraine. We had lots of suggestions. Some were
accepted; others were not. None of that is happening now. Not only is the
Ukrainian-American community not engaged in U.S.-Ukrainian policy, we don't
even know what the policy is. And that's troubling. So when's the next
meeting?
Andrew Fedynsky is director of the Ukrainian Museum-Archives in Cleveland,
Ohio. The museum's website: http://www.umacleveland.org/.
The Ukrainian Weekly, is an English-language newspaper published by
the Ukrainian National Association, 2200 Route 10, P. O. Box 280,
Parsippany, New Jersey 07054. Roma Hadzewycz is the Editor-in-chief.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER SIX
6. YUSHCHENKO: UKRAINE HAS TO FIND WAY TO DEMOCRACY
By E. Morgan Williams
ArtUkraine.com Information Service
Washington, D.C.
Friday, February 7, 2003
Washington, D.C.....Viktor Yushchenko, Chairman of the Nasha
Ukraina ("Our Ukraine") political bloc and Deputy in the Verkhovna
Rada, Ukraine's parliament, told a large audience in Washington, D.C.
Thursday evening that, "Ukraine has to find the way to democracy."
The former prime minister of Ukraine said, "Ukraine is facing its
deepest crisis since becoming independent in 1991. We are now faced
with the hard option of being ruled by oligarchic clan-driven authoritarian
governance or by the forces of democracy."
"Ukraine has to find the way to democracy, the democratic forces
must cooperate, coordinate, work together and present a unified front
in the 2004 elections " Yushchenko said at the briefing in Washington.
"Not to do so would be a total disaster for Ukraine and would
have a strong negative influence on the European situation and also
globally."
Viktor Yushchenko stated he believes Ukraine is a European
country and should be a member of the European family of nations.
"Ukraine must find its own way out of the present crisis and its
own way to democracy but needs the strong support of democratic
nations around the world," the political leader said.
"I am now visiting the United States, Poland, Germany, Sweden,
Russia, the Czech Republic and other countries to ask them and
their legislators to continue to support the development of democratic
forces and institutions in Ukraine. We also need their support to
ensure free, fair, and transparent elections in 2004," Yushchenko
reported to the receptive audience.
"Democratic nations should not in anyway isolate the people
of Ukraine. Ukraine does not deserve isolation. The people of
Ukraine are friendly toward democracy, they want democracy
and want to be integrated with the other democratic, free market
nations in the world."
Yushchenko closed his remarks by saying he believes
the forces of democracy will win in Ukraine and urges the
United States and other democracies to stay fully and totally
engaged with the people of Ukraine in their struggle to build
a strong, independent, democratic, free market country.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER SEVEN
Ed. Not a good decision by Voice of America. Ukraine Still Has A Long
Road
Ahead of it Regarding the Building of A Democratic State.
7. VOA MAKES SUBSTANTIAL CUTS IN PROGRAM TO UKRAINE
10 Eastern Europe Broadcasts To End
By Olga Dryzhanovska
The Washington Times
Washington, D.C.
February 7, 2003
The Voice of America will end its foreign-language service to 10
Eastern European countries under its 2004 budget, officials said this week.
The U.S. government-run service will shut down its services in
Bulgarian, Czech, Estonian, Hungarian, Latvian, Lithuanian, Polish, Slovene,
Slovak and Romanian, the officials said. There will also be substantial cuts
in its Ukrainian and Armenian services.
According to VOA management, the changes are motivated by strategic
rather than economic reasons. VOA's budget for 2004 was increased by 9.5
percent to $563.5 million.
But VOA wants to use the increased funding to develop programming aimed
at the Middle East and Southeast Asia. A total of $30 million will be used
to initiate the Middle East Television Network, a new satellite service in
Arabic. Indonesian programming will be doubled to five hours a week.
"Our world is changing," said VOA Director David Jackson in a
telephone interview. "Ever since VOA was created 62 years ago our countries
have changed as the geopolitical situation has changed."
Some analysts agree it's time for VOA to rethink its strategy. Simon
Serfaty, director of European studies at the Center for Strategic and
International Studies, said he was sympathetic to the decision to reduce the
European division.
"In the conditions of scarce resources, Europe doesn't hold that kind
of priority for pursuing such activity as other parts of the world," he
said.
VOA, supervised by the Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG), beams
about 1,000 hours of news, information, and educational and cultural
programs every week to an audience of about 94 million people worldwide in
more than 50 languages, according to the VOA Web site.
"We operate much like the private media journalistically," Mr. Jackson
said. "However, part of our mission is to report on the U.S. government and
its policies."
The BBG also oversees Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL), Radio
Sawa and Radio Farda in Arabic, Radio Free Asia , Radio and TV Marti, and
Worldnet Television.
RFE/RL, which was created to broadcast local news in countries where
free speech is suppressed, will also drop services in six languages:
Bulgarian, Croatian, Estonian, Latvian, Lithuanian and Slovak. Operational
costs of Armenian, Georgian, Serbian and Ukrainian services will be reduced
as well.
In a statement to VOA staff this week, BBG Chairman Kenneth Tomlinson
said the victory in the Cold War was a direct result of VOA broadcasts to
Eastern and Central Europe.
He said that "the goal these services struggled and sacrificed for has
been achieved, and they should take great pride in the role they played in
this historic mission."
Mr. Jackson said the broadcast service is doing its best to help
workers find new jobs. However, according to union leaders, many VOA
employees believe the European services are still needed.
UKRAINE REPORT No. 2, 2003: STORY NUMBER EIGHT
8. UKRAINE AND BELARUS, THOSE EASTERN SLAVS
FARCICAL PERFORMANCE
It is a bizarre performance to watch
Editorial
By The Baltic Times
Riga, Latvia
February 06, 2003
Those Eastern Slavs just don't know what to do. One week they're flirting
with the West, the next they're chumming it up among themselves, declaring
eternal friendships and establishing monetary unions. In all truthfulness,
it all looks like a grand farce, and one can't help but wonder how long the
self-delusional circus will go on.
Cold-shouldered at NATO's Prague summit, Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma,
who so earnestly wants to befriend the West, now finds himself an outcast.
What does he do? He runs to Vladimir Putin and declares undying loyalty,
when in the back of his mind he fantasizes about an alliance with Western
powers.
Banned by more than a dozen Western countries and the United States just
weeks after he was eschewed by the Kremlin, Belarus' Alexander Lukashenko
was forced to grovel on his knees in Moscow lest he become a complete
international pariah. The result? Belarus will become part of the ruble zone
on Jan. 1, 2005, completing the Eastern union about which so much ink has
been uselessly spilled.
It will never work. Simply because each country is going into the union with
completely different motivations (granted, selfish ones), a single monetary
zone uniting Russian and Belarus won't swing. Lukashenko wants access to the
printing press to pay off his debts and finance his deficit economy, while
Putin dreams of stretching Russian control right up to Poland's and
Lithuania's eastern border, making export deliveries to the West and
Kaliningrad exclave a whole lot easier.
The proposed ruble zone will fail once Minsk insists on having the right to
print fresh cash. This issue, by the way, is still undecided and is likely
to remain so. Belarus' economy amounts to some 2 percent of Russia's
(effectively just another region for Moscow), but Lukashenko insists that
his country would be a net contributor to the new union. So he should have
the right to print.
Putin, for its part, is soaking up all the attention the union is getting
from Lukashenko and Kuchma, and like a master ventriloquist, he will
manipulate them for all they are worth. To make the new union work, the
Kremlin has even promised a $300 million no-interest loan to Minsk that can
be paid back "at earliest convenience." Lukashenko is giddy with delight,
and one can't help but wonder what Russian taxpayers have to say about this.
It is all a joke. Then there will come a time when Belarus and Ukraine will
tire of this arrangement, and they will once again cozy up to the West and
the Eastern Slavs will be back to Act One. It is a bizarre performance to
watch.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER NINE
9. RUSSIA TAKES CONTROL OF CONTROVERSIAL ARMENIAN
NUCLEAR PLANT
"Built to the same design as the Chernobyl atomic power station in Ukraine."
"It also follows a trend in other ex-Soviet republics, such as Ukraine,
where Russian investors have aggressively snatched up banks, a broadcaster
and oil refineries."
By David Stern in Moscow
Financial Times
London, England, UK
February 08, 2003
Russia has assumed manage-ment of Armenia's sole nuclear power station and
main electricity producer, in exchange for $40m in fuel debts that Yerevan
owes Moscow.
The deal, announced this week, is the latest instance where Armenian
officials handed over prime pieces of industry to write off sums owed to
Russia. Yerevan last year likewise cleared around $100m in outstanding debt
by transferring ownership of five of the country's main enterprises,
including the main thermal power plant and an electronics factory.
Details of the agreement on the Metsamor nuclear power plant, located 30km
from the capital, were few, however. Officials said that Moscow would take
over financial management, while the plant itself, which provides around 40
per cent of Armenia's electricity needs, remained in Armenian hands.
Press reports said that Russia's Atomic Energy Ministry and RAO UES, the
Russian electricity monopoly, would pay off the Armenia's $32m debt to TVEL,
Russia's nuclear power operator. In addition, they would provide $8m to
purchase additional nuclear fuel.
"Starting this minute, we will never have to remember the plant had problems
with fuel supplies because of debts," said Ilya Klebanov, Russia's industry
and science minister, on conclusion of the agreement.
Metsamor has long been a centre of controversy. Built to the same design as
the Chernobyl atomic power station in Ukraine - the site of the world's
worst civilian nuclear accident - it is located on a highly sensitive
seismic fault line to boot. The plant was shut down following a devastating
earthquake in 1988, which levelled two towns and killed 25,000 people, but
restarted in 1995 in the midst of massive power shortages.
The European Union, in an effort to eliminate all Chernobyl-class nuclear
reactors, originally demanded that the plant be closed by 2004.
Armenian officials however have balked at the deadline. Decommissioning
could be a costly and disruptive process, they said. Metsamor not only helps
provide the country with round-the-clock power, but provides a margin to
export electricity to nearby Georgia.
Russia's acquisition of the plant and other Armenian enterprises underlines
the close relationship between Moscow and Yerevan, the Kremlin's closest
ally in the Caucasus.
It also follows a trend in other ex-Soviet republics, such as Ukraine, where
Russian investors have aggressively snatched up banks, a broadcaster and oil
refineries.
Armenian commentators say the deal has so far raised little interest among
the population, which is more preoccupied with the country's post-Soviet
economic crisis and presidential elections at the end of the month.
"Many people believe that it is a good thing that Russia has acquired all
these businesses, if only they would begin to work again," says Mark
Grigorian, a prominent local journalist.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2, STORY NUMBER TEN
10. CRACKDOWN ON ILLEGAL FERTILITY TREATMENT TRADE
Couples may also be attracted by the cheaper cost of fertility
treatment in Russia, the Ukraine, India and Greece.
First International Egg Donation Conference in London today.
Experts gather to set up egg-donation network to stop women
shopping abroad for expensive and dangerous treatments
By Sarah-Kate Templeton, Health Editor
Sunday Herald, Glasgow, UK
Sunday, February 9, 2003
A crackdown on the illegal trade in human eggs is being planned this
weekend with the establishment of a worldwide network to regulate
the industry in 'reproductive tourism'.
The burgeoning industry, whereby couples travel abroad to seek fertility
treatments which are outlawed in their own country, will be tackled by
experts gathered at the First International Egg Donation Conference in
London today.
In the last year, more than 50 infertile British couples travelled to Spain
to buy eggs from local women, a practice which is illegal in the UK. The
clinic they attended in Valencia is well-respected and boasts one of the
highest success rates in the world.
But treatment there is not cheap, costing around œ5000 for egg donation,
and specialists warn that greater controls need to be introduced to protect
patients who may be tempted, due to price or the types of treatments
offered, to attend less scrupulous clinics.
A key problem facing conference participants is the widely differing legal
restrictions in individual countries, which have resulted in couples with a
range of different requirements criss-crossing borders to shop for treatment
in an unregulated and potentially dangerous international marketplace.
The most common example of reproductive tourism is buying eggs but lesbian
couples may also need to travel outwith their own county for treatment. It
is illegal to use IVF to choose the sex of a child in the UK while the use
of surrogate mothers is banned in France and Spain.
In Spain, it is also illegal to receive a donated egg from someone you know,
such as a sister, while in Denmark it is illegal to receive a donated egg
from someone you do not know.
Couples may also be attracted by the cheaper cost of fertility treatment in
Russia, the Ukraine, India and Greece.
Dr Andjelka Stones-Abassi, organiser of the conference and co-founder
of the Global Egg Donation Resource, an information group, says a worldwide
etwork is necessary to ensure that the growing reproductive tourism industry
is safe and well-regulated.
'In the UK women are waiting for three or four years for egg donation. If a
patient can't get treatment in their own country they go somewhere else but
often they don't know anything about the clinic they are attending. We want
to set up a network of accredited clinics so that women don't fall into the
hands of people who don't know what they are doing.
'Parents are being misled at the moment, they are travelling to a clinic
because they have read an advert on a website or in the newspaper. They
are going to people who claim they can clone. It's crazy. Women travel to
Ukraine, Greece, Russia or India because treatment is cheaper and egg
donors are readily available. We would check that all the clinics in the
network were run by a reputable clinician.'
She added: 'For example, if a British couple cannot afford treatment in the
UK, we would look for a clinic elsewhere where the treatment is cheaper,
there are translators and the results are just as good.
'There is too much 'infertility business' around today and patients are
paying huge sums of money just to have a child. The demand is becoming
greater by the day.'
The global egg donation network was welcomed by Dr Paul Rainsbury,
clinical director of the Rainsbury Clinic at the Bupa Roding Hospital in
Ilford.
He sends his patients to a Spanish clinic for egg donation and to the US for
sex selection using pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). His egg
donation service, which makes it easier for British women to buy eggs from
Spain, has prompted calls for a change in the law in this country to pay
women who choose to donate.
Rainsbury agreed that, given the shortage of donated eggs in the UK,
reproductive tourism will continue to expand and must be monitored.
He said: 'I send patients to a clinic in Valencia for egg donation which, in
my view, is one of the best in the world. I have also sent patients to
Italy in the past and, at the moment, send patients to a clinic in the US
for sex selection which is illegal in this country.
'I have heard, however, that some women who have travelled to Eastern
Europe or Asia have had bad treatment or even the wrong treatment,' he
added.
The horror stories include taking a woman's eggs without consent, and
causing a woman to suffer ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome -- enlargement
of the ovaries caused by stimulating them with drugs to produce more eggs.
In mild form, this causes a swollen abdomen for several days but, when
severe, can cause thrombosis, kidney damage, breathing difficulties and even
death.
Other problems with disreputable clinics include failure to screen donated
sperm for such viruses as HIV and implanting women with the wrong
embryos --a mistake which recently occurred in the UK.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2, STORY NUMBER ELEVEN
11. MICROSOFT RESPONDS TO CRITICISMS THAT NEW SOFTWARE
USES "SURZHYK"
KYIV, UKRAINE...February 10, 2003..Responding to assertions being
made on some Internet websites that Microsoft has developed a laughable
mixed-language Ukrainian version of its popular Windows XP software,
the marketing director of its Kyiv office said that a huge misunderstanding
has taken place and pointed out that no full Ukrainian Windows XP
software package currently exists, according to a recent article by Roman
Woronowycz of the Kyiv Press Bureau of The Ukrainian Weekly.
"This is not a Ukrainian software version of Windows XP," explained
Valeria Kazban, "it is the interface pack. This is an effort to determine
whether this is market interest among Ukrainian users."
In an exclusive interview with The Ukrainian Weekly recently, Ms.
Kazban emphasized that the Ukrainian interface pack can be downloaded
free from Microsoft's website and that the company made it available for
public consumption to test demand.
However, she did not explain why this was not spelled out in the press
release issued by Microsoft when the new product came online. In a press
release, Microsoft Director of Product for the CIS Oleksii Badayev merely
stated that the Ukrainian interface pack "was produced to meet the needs
of Ukrainian buyers and to develop the variety of software programs with
a Ukrainian interface."
Ms. Kazban explained to The Ukrainian Weekly that this is not the
first time that Microsoft efforts have been misinterpreted. "I want it to
be known that there are always a variety of points of view on any new
Microsoft products," said Ms. Kazban.
The Microsoft marketing director for Ukraine explained that only
Microsoft's Office XP software is currently available in Ukrainian, and is
limited to the Word and Excel programs.
Regardless of the intermediary nature of the interface pack, some
visitors to the website http://www.maidan.org.ua went so far as to call
it a "surzhyk," or mixed Ukrainian-Russian anomaly.
The basic problem, as contributors to the open discussion on the
website suggested, is that the Ukrainian interface pack can be installed
only on Russian-language Windows XP software. If you are an English
interface user, or Polish, or German, or Chinese, you're out of luck,
for now anyway.
In addition, as Andrii Shevchuk, one contributor to the discussion,
pointed out in detail, there are several places where the program
inexplicably reverts back to the Russian language, particularly in
Outlook Express and the print mode of Word.
While Microsoft has translated the full line of its software into
many languages over the years, Ukraine has had to fight for any
Ukrainian-language version of Microsoft programming, Even though
Polish- and Russian-language software has been available for around
a decade, Roman Woronowycz wrote in his article.
Ukrainian software appeared only last March, and that came only
after a concerted effort by Ukraine's Ministry of Education and the
Shevchenko Scientific Society of America, which is based in New
York according to The Ukrainian Weekly article of January 19.
Microsoft eventually signed an agreement with Ukraine's
Ministry of Education to produce Office XP in the Ukrainian
language for the benefit of Ukrainian schools, many of which are
computerized today.
Ms. Kazban underscored that the latest Microsoft initiative to
explore a Ukrainian version of the more popular Windows version is
not prompted by outside forces, but this time came from within the
company itself. Ms. Kazban said that a decision on future Microsoft
software in the Ukrainian language will be made after marketing tests
are completed.
The Ukrainian Weekly is an English-language weekly newspaper
published by The Ukrainian National Association and is headquartered
in Parsippany, New Jersey, USA. Roman Woronowycz is the editor
of The Ukrainian Weekly's Kyiv Press Bureau.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER TWELVE
12. UKRAINIAN SPRINTERS BLOCK AND DOVGAL WIN IN EUROPE
UKRAINE'S ZHANNA BLOCK WINS 60 METER DASH AT FLANDERS
INDOOR TRACK MEET IN GHENT, BELGIUM
UKRAINIAN SPRINTER ANATOLIY DOVGAL RAN AWAY WITH THE
MEN'S 60 METER SPRINT IN BUDAPEST, HUNGARY
ArtUkraine.com; A/P; and IAAF
February 9, 2003
Kyiv, Ukraine, Sun., Feb. 9, 2003......Ukrainian champion sprinters
Zhanna Block and Anatoliy Dovgal both win the 60 meters dash this weekend in
separate track meets held in Ghent, Belgium and Budapest, Hungary.
Ukraine's Zhanna Block equaled her mark this year in the 60 meters
dash and Coby Miller of the United States ran the season's fastest 60 meters
race Sunday to dominate the Flanders Indoor Energizer track meet held in
Ghent, Belgium.
In the women's 60 meter, Zhanna Block faced her toughest competition
from Merlene Ottey, a 42-year-old veteran, who is racing for Slovenia.
Block, the outdoor 100 meter world champion, finished in 7.09 to equal her
best mark this year. She beat Merlene Ottey by .09 seconds. Muriel Hurtis of
France finished third in 7.20.
On Saturday Ukrainian sprinter Anatoliy Dovgal ran away with the win
in the men's 60 meter sprint ahead Gabor Dobos, the home crowd favorite, at
the 2nd Enternet Cup International Association of Athletics Federation
(IAAF) Indoor Meeting held in Budapest, Hungary.
Dovgal clocked 6.68 seconds in the preliminaries ahead of Dobos' 6.79
seconds, then cut half-a-tenth off his time to win the meet with a season's
best of 6.63 seconds. Andrea Rabion of Italy finished third with a time of
6.64 seconds. Dejan Vojnovic of Croatia was fourth in 6.76, Geza Pauer
of Hungary was 5th with a time of 6.86 and the runner from Croatia, Jurica
Grabusic was sixth finishing in 6.90 seconds.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2: STORY NUMBER THIRTEEN
13. U.S. OFFICIAL ILLEGALLY SOLD VISAS ABROAD
In January 2000, he met with a Ukrainian "broker" in a Prague beer hall
Once the forms were processed, Meerovich would approve the visas without
interviewing the applicants -- most often Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians
By Neely Tucker
Washington Post Staff Writer
The Washington Post, Washington, D.C.
Saturday, February 8, 2003; Page A03
Selling visas was a good business for State Department employee Alexander J.
Meerovich while he was assigned to the U.S. Embassy in Prague, but the deal
came to an end this week when he pleaded guilty to fraud charges in federal
court.
Meerovich, 37, of Burke pleaded guilty before U.S. District Judge Ricardo M.
Urbina in Washington on Thursday, acknowledging that he sold at least 85
fraudulent visas in two years while deputy consul general at the embassy in
the Czech Republic. Justice Department prosecutors said he netted about
$50,000.
Under terms of the plea agreement, Meerovich will probably face a prison
term of 21 to 27 months when Urbina sentences him June 3.
"The illegal sales of U.S. visas strikes at the very heart of the
government's efforts to secure our borders and protect the national
security," said Michael Chertoff, assistant attorney general in charge of
the criminal division.
A person answering the telephone at Meerovich's home yesterday said he was
not available for comment.
Meerovich was a career Foreign Service officer when he arrived in Prague in
August 1999, having completed a three-year stint in the U.S. consulate
office in St. Petersburg, Russia, according to the plea agreement. As deputy
consul general in his new posting, he was assigned to interview visa
applicants, review applications and approve non-immigrant visas. He was also
the embassy's anti-fraud officer.
But in January 2000, he met with a Ukrainian "broker" in a Prague beer hall,
and the pair set up a plan to sell fraudulent visas, prosecutors said. Under
the plan, the Ukrainian would give Meerovich a set of applications,
including a $250 fee for each file, to be placed in the consulate's
applications intake box.
Once the forms were processed, Meerovich would approve the visas without
interviewing the applicants -- most often Czechs, Slovaks and Ukrainians,
according to the plea agreement. The plan was later revised, and Meerovich's
fee doubled. The scheme began to unravel when the embassy discovered that
Meerovich had approved people who had been rejected, authorities said.
UKRAINE REPORT 2003, No. 2, Monday, February 10 , 2003
For personal and academic use only.
|